The right choice depends on what you want to do after the MBA. A person who studied management at IIT Roorkee and later spent a year at a newer IIM says that if you want to excel in technology-oriented roles, the IIT programme is a strong choice, and that you do not need to be an engineer to understand the nuances of technology. If you are not sure of your interest yet, the IIM is the safer option.
The same person adds that IIMs are far better on academic rigour, so you will leave as a more polished professional. Some students on the IIM side go further and say that the management-first environment makes the IIM the obvious choice if fees are not a constraint, and that IIM placement reports are audited, whereas they feel the IIT averages and medians are not as high as they look.
On the other hand, an IIT tag can open doors if you plan to build a career abroad or in a technical domain, and the smaller batch can help with individual attention. IIM Udaipur and IIM Trichy are newer campuses, so also check how recent cycles have gone, particularly for your specialisation.
Put the latest placement reports of all three side by side. Look at the median, the number of recruiters, the sectors and the fees. Then match them against your own plan, and speak to students who are on campus now.
To draw a specific comparison between the 3 B Schools you have mentioned I will simply compare their placement statistics in a tabular form.
|
Particulars |
IIT Roorkee |
IIM Udaipur |
IIM Trichy |
|
Number of Recruiters |
53 |
184 |
110 |
|
Highest CTC |
INR 25.8 LPA |
INR 35.96 LPA |
INR 34 LPA |
|
Average CTC |
INR 16.8 LPA. |
INR 19.5 LPA |
INR 17.01 LPA |
|
Top Recruiters |
KPMG, Accenture, Deloitte |
American Express, Asian Paints, PwC |
Amazon, Dell, Nomura |