For most students in this dilemma, particularly engineers who are interested in analytics or technology-linked roles, IIT Madras tends to win on return on investment. Comments from students who were choosing between the two lean that way, with some adding that the IIT's placement reporting seems more trustworthy than the newer IIM's.
That said, the IIM is not a poor option. Even those who favour IIT Madras acknowledge that IIM Nagpur is decent, and the IIM name will matter to some recruiters and to family and peers. The newer IIMs also give you the benefit of a management-first environment, although you should read their placement reports carefully and check how many students actually took part and what the median looks like.
What decides it is your career plan:
Before choosing, speak with alumni and students on both campuses and ask them about recruiters, the roles they received and how the placement process worked. A short conversation with a few seniors will tell you more than any general opinion, including mine.
Among students who have faced exactly this choice, the leaning is towards IIT Madras, with some conditions.
IIM Nagpur has the IIM tag, a residential B-school setting and a general management focus. The tag matters for recruiters in certain sectors and for your long-term network, so it is not an obviously worse option. When placements for the two look close, forum users suggest comparing ROI after fees, global reputation and the specific roles you are targeting.
A practical approach is to pull the latest placement reports and compare the median package, the share of the batch placed, the sector mix and the total programme fee. Then talk to alumni from both institutes who work in roles you want, and ask who is leading the programme now, since leadership shapes recruiters.
If you want analytics, technology management or operations roles, Madras is the stronger default. If you want general management with the IIM label, Nagpur is a fair choice.
If you ask me, I would suggest you choose IIT Madras to pursue an MBA as compared to IIM Nagpur for an MBA.
If you want my honest opinion here it is. I would choose neither of the colleges you mentioned. My opinion is based on the following reasons.
But if you have no other options at all, then IIM Nagpur seems the better of the two. It is in the process of developing so maybe in some years it earns the credibility it owes to the IIM family and lives up to its name. Also some blind companies still prefer IIM students over other B Schools.