Most students who discuss this choice lean towards IIT Roorkee, but the margin depends on your plans. Student rankings place the IIT ahead of IIM Sirmaur, and one commenter says a good number of Sirmaur students were still unplaced at the time, so you should look closely at recent placement outcomes there.
The IIM name does help, and Sirmaur is part of the IIM system, so the brand benefit is growing. However, people point out that the newer IIMs are still building recruiter relationships, and that a name by itself does not bring companies to a remote campus. IIT Roorkee, in comparison, has a long-established parent brand, a stronger alumni network and recruiters that are used to visiting.
Also keep your own goals in mind:
Before you decide, compare the last two placement reports on number of students placed, median package and the sectors that hired. Then speak with seniors on both campuses about the reality on the ground, since reported figures and what students experience can differ.
I don’t even need to ponder over this question for a long time. The answer is very simple. You should choose IIT Roorkee over IIM Sirmaur for MBA. The reason being its new establishment. People don’t care if you are an IIM student unless you belong to the older ones. The new IIMs are yet to make a mark in the industry especially the likes of IIM Jammu and Sirmaur.
IIT Roorkee on the other hand is very good at placements and peer learning. Given the current situation of both institutes, IIT Roorkee is definitely the better option. The IIM tag offered by Sirmaur lacks credibility and even if it will be beneficial, it will be after some years and not right away.