If you are choosing purely between these two for an MBA, most students who have compared them lean towards IIT Roorkee. Their reasoning is that Roorkee offers better average placements, a stronger overall brand and a good return on investment, and good roles come to its management department. Several students rank Roorkee above IIM Amritsar, though a few put them roughly on par, so treat the lean as a lean and not a rule.
IIM Amritsar has the IIM name, which matters in some corporate circles and for certain profiles. However, students noted that its placements had a poor stretch in a recent cycle, and that the published report drew criticism. Among newer IIMs, some students also prefer IIM Jammu over Amritsar because its placements appeared to be doing better. That tells you these newer campuses can swing from one batch to another, so do not rely on the brand alone.
My advice is to compare the latest placement report of each programme directly, looking at:
If those numbers are close, Roorkee is the safer pick on brand and return on investment, while Amritsar suits you if the IIM label matters to your plans.
Most students who compare these two lean towards IIT Roorkee, though the choice depends on your target role. Student rankings put the IIT ahead of IIM Amritsar, and one student summarised it as better average pay, brand and return on investment, with good roles coming to Roorkee.
IIM Amritsar has the advantage of the IIM tag and a much larger batch. On the other hand, a few students say the campus had a hard time in a recent placement season and that its report did not satisfy them. Treat that as opinion and check the latest official report yourself, because outcomes change from year to year.
To decide, set the last two placement reports next to each other and look at the median and the number of recruiters rather than the highest package. Also compare the fees and ask current students what the recruiting experience was like.
IIT Roorkee is a better option for an MBA. It is not just the IIM tag that one should consider while choosing a business school. There are various factors like the establishment year of an institute, course fee, location, placement scenario, faculty, infrastructure, alumni network, etc. that must be considered during the selection.
IIT Roorkee is a well-established institution with a long history of excellence. Its Department of Management Studies (DoMS) has been functioning since 1998. On the other hand, IIM Amritsar is one of the newer IIMs in India, having been established in 2015.
Here are the MBA placement statistics of both DoMS (IIT Roorkee) and IIM Amritsar for 2023:
| PARTICULARS | (DoMS) IIT ROORKEE | IIM AMRITSAR |
|---|---|---|
| Number of Recruiters | 50+ | 110+ |
| Total number of students | 69 | 212 |
| Highest CTC | INR 25.8 LPA | INR 25.21 LPA |
| Average CTC | INR 16.8 LPA | INR 14.63 LPA |
| Median CTC | INR 18 LPA | INR 13.54 LPA |
| Top Recruiters | Deloitte, EY, Paytm, ICICI Bank, Vedanta, Infosys, etc. | Accenture, Cognizant, Dell, Deloitte, Genpact, and others. |
IIT Roorkee offers good placements, but more than that, it provides a rich academic environment to its students. The students of DoMS don’t just interact with each other, but also with the students of other departments like engineering. This enhances their understanding of things, and helps in the exchange of diverse perspectives.
IIT Roorkee is much older to IIM Amritsar, which is why it offers a rich alumni network and a strong brand name.
Because of these reasons, I would recommend you choose IIT Roorkee over IIM Amritsar for an MBA.
Let’s compare both colleges through their respective placement statistics.
|
Particulars |
IIM Amritsar |
IIT Roorkee |
|
Number of Recruiters |
110+ |
|
|
Number of students |
212 |
69 |
|
Highest CTC |
INR 25.21 LPA |
INR 25.8 LPA |
|
Average CTC |
INR 14.63 LPA |
INR 16.8 LPA |
|
Median CTC |
INR 13.54 LPA |
INR 18 LPA |
|
Top Recruiters |
Accenture, Cognizant, Dell, Deloitte, Genpact |
Deloitte, EY, Paytm, Axtria, NatWest, ICICI Bank, HCL, Vedanta, Infosys |