Average package comparisons between IITs can be misleading, and a student in the discussion explained why.
A higher average doesn't necessarily mean a better placement outcome for the typical student. Another contributor warns that stats on many websites are shared without context, so verify them with official reports.
My advice is to compare the median, the percentage of students placed and the branch-wise data for the department you care about, instead of one headline number.
It is possible, and it does not mean Mandi is better overall. Average package is one of the easiest numbers to misread.
First, check whether the statistics cover the same groups. Some institutes publish combined numbers for B.Tech, M.Tech, PhD and other programmes, while others report only the undergraduate batch or only a few departments. Mixing these gives a misleading comparison. A student answering the same question adds that you should also look at the placement percentage, not just the average. If only a small share of a batch gets very large offers while the rest get none, the average of those who were placed can look excellent even though many students were left out.
Second, the average depends on the department. Institutes with a strong computing intake can show a higher average than a larger institute with many core branches. A smaller cohort can also swing the number from year to year.
So when you see a headline like this, compare the same branch at both places, check how many students sat for placement, and ask how many received offers. Also be sceptical of any single claimed package without proof. The branch you get, and your own skills, will decide your outcome far more than the institute's average.
I would like to point out that the average package depends on the department and not the whole institution. So, yes some departments in IIT mandi are performing better than IIT Guwahati hence resulting in higher packages.
Firstly, I don’t think that the average package of IIT Mandi is more than IIT Guwahati. I think you are confused and looking at the placement statistics of different departments, disciplines, and programs. IIT Guwahati usually releases combined placement statistics for B.Tech, M.Tech, Ph.D., and other programs.
Even if this wasn’t the case, one should look at the placement percentage which denotes the ratio of people that applied for placements and those who got placed. Considering this, there are 2 instances under which IIT Mandi’s average can be higher than IIT Guwahati's.
Thus, I don’t find it logical to compare the mean only. Mode and Median should also be given due importance. The placement statistics are said to be appropriate only if Mean Mode and Median are almost similar. Having a high Mean literally means that a handful of students got high packages while the majority of the batch received below-average packages.
All I mean is that comparing two institutes on the basis of their average packages is not justified. I don’t necessarily mean IIT Guwahati is better than IIT Mandi.