You are choosing between two good institutes, so the deciding factor is what the specialisation offers you, not just the IIT label.
Students who commented on IIT Gandhinagar's M.Tech say that the academic programme itself is quite good, but that placements have not matched the high entry cutoffs of that institute. They add that it has been improving over the past few years and is still developing. At IIT Bhubaneswar, the machine design stream is described as focused on design, analysis, finite element methods and lab work, which suits you if you want to go deep on mechanical components and simulation.
Before you accept either call, confirm three things directly with each department:
Also check whether a stipend or assistantship is available, since this changes your effective cost.
If your plan is research or a PhD, pick the lab and guide with the best fit. If you plan to go to industry, weigh recent placement data and your own CAD, FEA and programming skills more heavily than the institute name.
I think you should go for M.Tech in Mechanical Systems Design at IIT Bhubaneswar. IIT Gandhinagar offers an M.Tech in Mechanical Engineering, but not specifically in Machine Design.
IIT Bhubaneswar is placed #47 in the Engineering category as per the NIRF 2023 Ranking. The School of Mechanical Sciences at IIT Bhubaneswar has fully equipped labs. It has a state-of-the-art computing lab with thirty workstations connected to an eighteen-blade server.
Here’s a comparison between IIT Bhubaneswar and IIT Gandhinagar:
|
Parameters |
IIT Bhubaneswar Mechanical Systems Design |
IIT Gandhinagar Overall |
|
NIRF 2023 Engineering Ranking |
47 |
18 |
|
Placement % (2023) |
100 % |
76.22% |
|
Highest Package (2023) |
INR 11.90 LPA |
- |
|
Average Package (2023) |
INR 8.58 LPA |
INR 19.34 LPA |
|
Median Package (2023) |
INR 9.80 LPA |
INR 15.18 LPA |
|
Top Recruiters on Campus (2023) |
Google, Microsoft, Reliance Industries, Accenture Japan, Caterpillar |
Accenture, Amul, Cognizant, Deloitte, Adobe |
(The M.Tech placements data is not available for IIT Gandhinagar)
Although IIT Gandhinagar has a slightly higher ranking than IIT Bhubaneswar, the Mechanical Sciences Department at IIT Bhubaneswar has a much better overall value.
I would recommend you choose IIT Bhubaneswar Mechanical Systems Design over IIT Gandhinagar Mechanical for your M.Tech degree.