The right pick depends on what you want to do after the MBA. If you are clear that you want a career in human resources, MDI Gurgaon's HR programme is the more natural fit. Management at IIT Delhi is a general management degree, and although you can choose electives of your interest, an alumnus noted that final placements rarely brought HR-specific roles.
IIT Delhi gives you a wider range of roles, with analytics, consulting and operations being popular, and its technology orientation and brand are useful for those paths. If your main criterion is return on investment and you have not decided on a specialisation, a general management programme like this keeps your options open. A student also said that those who are only certain about HR should consider an HR-focused programme instead, as the general roles from some HR schools can be limited.
If your interest is operations or consulting rather than HR, the argument tilts towards IIT Delhi because of its engineering network and the tech and analytics recruiters it attracts. MDI Gurgaon has established corporate recruiter relationships and a strong alumni presence in general management and consulting, so it remains a solid alternative.
Look at the last placement report of each programme, check which sectors and roles recruited from the specialisation you want, and talk to a couple of current students. That will tell you more than any ranking list.
The answer turns on whether you are certain about HR. A former DMS IIT Delhi student from the 2016 to 2018 batch says DMS is a general management degree. You can pick electives of your choice, but there are hardly any jobs related to HR, and during his final placements no company came to offer HR roles, although a couple of students did get HR internships. If HR is your target career, he suggests MDI Gurgaon's PGP-HRM.
The flip side is breadth. A student comparing DMS IIT Delhi with an HR programme at TISS said that if you are only sure about HR you should go for TISS, while DMS gives far greater and more varied roles. This pattern holds for MDI as well. A specialised HR programme sharpens your profile for HR recruiters but narrows your options if you change your mind later.
So decide on certainty. Choose MDI PGP-HRM if you are committed to a career in human resources, and want a specialised course, since you will have a well-defined recruiter pool. Choose DMS IIT Delhi if you want flexibility across consulting, analytics, operations and general management roles, and an IIT brand. Review the most recent placement reports for both, check fees, and talk to alumni who work in the roles you want before choosing.
The decision comes down to whether you want a career in HR. A graduate of DMS IIT Delhi says that if you want to pursue HR after your MBA, MDI's PGP-HRM is the better choice. DMS is a general management degree, and although you can choose electives, there are hardly any HR jobs at placement time. The same graduate recalls that a couple of students got HR internship offers but no company came for HR final placements, though no student was interested at the time.
If you haven't yet decided on your specialisation and ROI is your main criterion, the same person strongly suggested taking the DMS offer, because a general management degree from an IIT gives you access to a wider range of roles. Another student advising on a similar choice between an IIT MBA and a specialised HR programme says the IIT offers far more diverse roles, while the specialised HR school makes sense only if you're certain about HR. One caution is that DMS placements lean towards analytics and consulting roles, so check the variety yourself.
So ask yourself if you're sure about HR. If yes, MDI PGP-HRM. If you're unsure, want flexibility and a strong brand in Delhi, DMS IIT Delhi is the safer choice. Check the latest placement reports for both, and talk to current students, because these accounts come from earlier batches.
Bring a student of DMS Delhi myself I can surely help guide you with some insights. However, I have very limited knowledge about MDI Gurgaon PGP-HRM.
This entirely depends on your preferences. If you want to pursue a career in human resources after earning your MBA, enroll in the MDI PGP-HRM program.
DMS at IIT Delhi is a general management degree, and while you can choose any electives you want, there are few jobs in HR. If your primary criterion is ROI and you haven't yet decided which specialization to pursue, you should strongly consider accepting the offer from DMS, IIT Delhi. You'll have plenty of time to decide on a specialization anyway.
In terms of the profiles offered during final placements, there isn't much difference between MDI and DMS, IIT Delhi; however, the overall popularity of MDI is slightly higher than DMS, IIT Delhi; this is also due to the fact that DMS doesn't advertise itself much, and as a private b-school, MDI has that advantage to market itself.