This depends on what you value most, and students who are actually on these campuses are split.
Be realistic about workload and cost. Students describe IIIT Allahabad as demanding, with a heavy curriculum, and it costs more than the NITs. One student estimated the four-year total at roughly 8 to 9 lakh including hostel and other expenses, against a lower figure for NITs, so check the current fee schedule before you decide.
I could not find first-hand feedback on NSUT CSAI, so compare it separately using its latest placement report and talk to a current student. As a rule of thumb, pick IIIT Allahabad IT if coding and placements are your priority and you can handle pressure. Pick MNNIT CS if you want a more balanced four years, a stronger brand tag and lower fees.
Both IIIT Allahabad and MNNIT are highly regarded engineering colleges in North India offering premium quality education. Placements-wide, MNNIT CSE is slightly better compared to both NSUT and IIITA. In my opinion, the preference order should be
MNNIT CSE >= IIITA IT > NSUT CS/AI
MNNIT is the first choice because it’s on Eid the top 5 NITs with the most sought-after branch CSE. IIIT Allahabad is also a great choice for CSE because it has a CS-tailored curriculum and ambiance.
Overall I feel if you are certain of joining an IT company, and have an interest in coding and computers go for IIIT Allahabad IT or MNNIT Allahabad. If you are unsure of your branch preference go for NSUT.
MNNIT Allahabad, Allahabad
IIIT Allahabad, Allahabad