Third-generation IITs are worth your time if you pick the branch carefully and have realistic expectations. Defenders say the IIT faculty selection standard is the same in new and old IITs, and that a young IIT is still better for learning than many older private colleges. A senior at one of them adds that the coding culture is active, with clubs running and students winning hackathons, though smaller batches mean fewer people in each activity.
The critics make fair points too. One reply says a new IIT will improve but will never sit at the level of IIT Delhi, and another warns of tougher living conditions and a thinner alumni network. Several students advise that if you can get circuital branches at a second-generation IIT, that's usually the safer play.
What the IIT tag does give you is a real advantage if you plan an MBA, UPSC or a masters abroad, according to students weighing it against state colleges like VJTI and COEP. If your goal is only a software job, a strong CSE seat elsewhere may serve you equally well.
My advice: choose a branch you actually like, check the latest placement report for it, and talk to current students before locking in.
If someone has a passion for engineering, 3rd generation IITs are better than many non-IITs.
This is because the faculty of new IITs is as good as that in the old ones. There’s no compromise at all in the faculty selection process of any IIT. The professors are all genuine and certified experts in their respective fields.
When 2nd and 3rd gen IITs were created, the professors of old IITs were given the choice of continuing beyond retirement. This was done so that no IIT faces a shortage of faculty.
Though the new IITs can’t offer top notch facilities, the learning opportunities in them are good enough. But if packages and placements are talked about, then obviously they won’t be very high for IIT Tirupati in its formative years.
If you’re passionate about engineering, you should consider IIT Tirupati. With talent, skill and passion, you’ll easily land a decent job off campus.