Short answer: students lean towards IIM Udaipur over IIM Ranchi, but the margin is a matter of opinion rather than fact. In ranking debates among aspirants, Udaipur keeps appearing near the top of the newer IIMs, while Ranchi tends to appear lower.
The better way to choose is by your priorities:
When the options are close, perception will end up counting, and that favours Udaipur at present.
Also keep in mind that both campuses are young. The alumni network is a decade or so old, which means you'll need to build your own contacts. Speak to current students on both campuses before accepting.
There is no single correct ranking between the newer IIMs, and students themselves disagree. In online discussions IIM Udaipur is usually placed ahead of IIM Ranchi, with one list putting Udaipur above Trichy and Ranchi, and another placing Ranchi near the bottom of the newer group. So if you hold both offers and have no other preference, Udaipur gets the nod from most students.
That said, I wouldn't decide on perception alone. Pull up the placement report and curriculum of both and check which has stronger options in the area you want, whether finance, marketing or operations. Look at exchange programmes and research orientation too if those matter to you.
Remember that newer IIMs have smaller alumni bases than older B-schools, so your own profile and effort count heavily in placements. Use LinkedIn to see where recent alumni from each campus actually work.
There is no definitive ranking between IIM Udaipur and IIM Ranchi, and I'd be wary of anyone who claims otherwise. Still, student discussions generally rate Udaipur higher among the newer IIMs, and Ranchi usually appears below it.
Make the call in three steps:
Be realistic about the newer-IIM trade-off too: the alumni base is smaller than at older institutes, so you'll rely more on your own profile and effort during placements.
Speak to a couple of current students on each campus before you decide, because they can describe the culture and the recruiters better than any report.
Many students would pick IIM Udaipur if they had to choose between it and IIM Ranchi. Among the newer IIMs, discussions often list Udaipur near the top and Ranchi toward the lower end, but those are opinions, not official rankings.
Use your own criteria. If you want a particular field, check which campus offers more subjects and better placement opportunities in it. If you want to build a research profile, see which one encourages that. If exposure matters, compare student exchange options. Doing this homework tells you far more than any forum ranking.
Also note that newer IIMs have smaller alumni networks, so the first years of your career will depend on your own profile. Visit or talk to current students before you decide, and speak to a couple on each campus, because they can describe the culture and the recruiters better than any report.
If you are comparing these two IIMs, the honest answer is that it depends on priorities, though Udaipur has the edge in perception. Aspirants who rank the newer IIMs tend to place Udaipur higher than Ranchi.
Here's how I'd decide:
If after all of that you still see no real difference, perception is a fair tie-breaker, because recruiters and peers do form views of an institute. Keep in mind that newer IIMs don't yet have the deep alumni base of older ones, so networking will be on you.