There is no single reason, and several factors work together. Students who compare the two point to selectivity as one: BITS Pilani has long attracted a large share of high JEE performers and admits through its own entrance test, so the peer group tends to be strong. That cycle of strong peers, strong alumni and strong recruiters feeds on itself, and it builds a national brand over time.
Another difference students mention is administration. One commenter described BITS as better managed, with student-friendly processes such as getting documents like a bonafide certificate through an online request that is delivered to the hostel room, whereas such tasks are slower at Mesra. Others add that BITS built a national identity with multiple campuses, a flexible curriculum and a Practice School programme, while BIT Mesra remained more regional.
None of this means BIT Mesra is a poor college. It has a long history, a good campus and many successful alumni, and it is a solid option in the eastern region. If you are choosing between them, compare the branch, fees, latest placement reports and your home state, since one student advised that the decision depends on risk appetite and location. Talk to seniors at both campuses and look at where recent graduates work, rather than relying on fame alone.
The gap in fame is less about age and more about how each institute was run and who it attracted. Students who know both campuses say BITS Pilani draws a much higher share of students who have cleared top engineering entrance exams, and it has no reserved seats, so the peer group tends to be very strong. That peer group, along with a large alumni network, keeps feeding the brand.
Students also point to management style. BITS is described as student friendly, with administrative tasks such as getting a certificate handled online and delivered to the hostel, whereas at Mesra the same task can mean writing an application and waiting in line outside an office. Over many years these small differences shape how students feel about their college and how loudly they speak for it.
Location and positioning matter too. Pilani and its newer campuses have built a strong national and international reputation, while BIT Mesra has stayed more regional, and is often seen as a good option mainly for students from the east.
If you are choosing between them today, look at the branch, the campus and the placement record for your specific course, not just the brand.
BIT Mesra, even today is a premiere Indian Institution which was established alongside IIT Kharagpur in the 1950s. The alumni from BIT Mesra have made great contributions in their respective fields in the past. At one time, BIT Mesra had an admission criteria which was eventually scrapped due to unethical practices used during the admissions.
The reason why BIT Mesra has lagged far behind BITS Pilani is that it is not evolving with the fast-paced world. BIT Mesra is not making any significant changes in its academics to compete with other premier Indian universities.
BITS Pilani has adapted with time. Both the motivated students and the education quality at BITS Pilani make it stand high above BIT Mesra.BITS Pilani has no attendance criteria for its students. Even then, the students like to attend the classes due to a healthy teaching environment.
BITS Pilani was established by G.D. Birla in collaboration with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, USA. Its academic program flowcharts are thus derived from MIT. BIT Mesra, on the other hand, has no collaborative backing as such. The practical learning environment at BITS Pilani stands much higher than the rote learning mindset at BIT Mesra.
The faculty at BITS Pilani is excellent in terms of knowledge, interest, and supporting nature. On the other hand, the faculty at BIT Mesra is not favored by the students. The students find the faculty at BIT Mesra to be very rigid and dominating which causes hurdles in a healthy teacher-student relationship.
To regain its lost status, BIT Mesra should adopt more modern learning methods, a well-adaptive curriculum, and a more supportive faculty like BITS Pilani.
BITS Pilani is located in Rajasthan, which is and used to be a part of India's so-called active north. As a result, BIT Mesra is not preferred by the people of the north, who have better options of IITs and NITs. While some go for the south. It is only an ideal place for Bihar, Bengal, Orisha, Jharkhand, and the neighboring state.
BIT Mesra was ranked 7th by India Today Group Survey, but it remains isolated in terms of fame because students are the biggest marketer for a deemed institution. If you say, “Hey, I am from Bit Mesra,” the likely answer would be, “Is it a subsidiary unit of Bits Pilani?” As BITS Pilani is more reputed.
Here are a few other reasons why BIT Mesra has not gained much recognition among the students.
This all that I have learned through my connections at the institutes. Hope this helps in clearing your doubts.