For most students the answer is IT at IIEST Shibpur, and the reasoning has little to do with the branch name. IT and CSE overlap heavily in what they teach, and a former student says IT fundamentals share a lot with CS. So the title on your degree matters far less than the college that issues it and the peer group you study with.
Students who discuss Kolkata colleges tend to be blunt about this comparison. One says IIEST is comparable to a tier-1.5 NIT and that private options in the city are not worth comparing with it. IEM was named among the colleges that people say should not be put in the same bracket as Shibpur. Another student, answering a different choice, says IIEST CSE gives better career opportunities in industry and academics than a niche core branch at an older institute.
Keep in mind that IIEST has its own drawbacks, including small shared hostel rooms, slow administration and a mostly regional student body. Even so, an institute-of-national-importance tag, a competitive peer group and a stronger recruiter pool usually outweigh a branch label. Check the fee difference and the latest placement report for both before you finalise.
Here is some information to assist you in choice-making-
Snapdeal, Amazon, Google, etc. visit IIEST Shibpur and offer equal placement opportunities to both IT and CSE students. My roommate from IT got into Snapdeal through campus placement.
IEM isn’t a well-known college. It is a local college unlike IIEST, which is an institute of national importance. The campus size of IEM is very small. Big companies don’t usually visit small colleges like IEM.
The college tag has a value of its own. Besides, the opportunities and exposure offered by IIEST are immense.
Thus, I would recommend you opt for IT at IIEST Shibpur.
IEM Kolkata (IEM Saltlake), Kolkata