












The picture from students is mixed, and it leans towards BITS Pilani for the experience and towards the IIT brand for long-term credentials. One student comparing IIT Patna with BITS Pilani electronics and instrumentation says Pilani is the better option given its infrastructure and opportunities, because a newer IIT does not offer the same experience as the old IITs. You do get the IIT tag and smaller batches, though, which let you know everyone and take part in clubs.
Consider also how placements work in electrical and electronics. A BITS alumnus describes core electrical hiring as tough, since on-campus companies prefer to hire master's students, and in his time few B.E. graduates got core roles through campus. This was an older experience, so check how recent batches have fared. For a new IIT such as Gandhinagar, the benefits are the IIT brand, government-funded research, and a smaller cohort, which suits people who may want a PhD or master's.
My practical advice is to compare the specific programmes:
Look at recent placement outcomes for electrical at each, and speak to current students.
Chemical engineering at both IIT Hyderabad and IIT Gandhinagar can lead to a good career, but graduates will tell you that the branch label matters less than how well you do within it. A former IIT Gandhinagar student who knows many chemical engineers there put it this way: if you are among the top performers, scope is everywhere, and the institute matters less than your own standing in the class.
Another thing to understand is that chemical engineers rarely stay in a single lane. Alumni describe batchmates moving into software and IT, business analytics, consulting, entrepreneurship, banking and civil services, with the aptitude and problem solving from the branch carrying over. Core roles in process design, pharmaceuticals and energy exist, but they are fewer, so many students plan for higher studies, a PhD or a switch to analytics or data science.
Both campuses run this programme as a newer department, so there are fewer batches to look at than at older IITs, and one graduate warned against judging placements from a single year. Look at several years of the department's placement reports instead.
My advice: pick the branch only if you enjoy it, keep your CGPA strong, build coding and data skills alongside it, and compare the latest departmental placement and higher-study outcomes at both institutes before deciding.

No ranking is completely reliable, and NIRF is best used as one input rather than as a final verdict. It scores institutes on several parameters, including teaching and learning resources, research, graduation outcomes, outreach and perception, and different institutes can do well on some of these and poorly on others.
Students point out the weak spots:
Because of this, students suggest not using placements as the only measure of a college, and treating the top institutes as broadly equivalent for placements.
So there is no simple answer on whether IIT Bhubaneswar is better than IIT Gandhinagar. Compare them on what matters to you, such as your branch, faculty in that department, labs, recent branch-wise placements, internship culture and campus life. Use NIRF as a starting filter, then speak to seniors in your branch before making a final decision.
Both options are core materials-focused branches, so the real question is what you want to do with the degree. Students who have looked at materials and metallurgy in Indian IITs are fairly frank that the scope in India is limited, with a small number of places for R&D and few industries that hire in volume. A final-year student of the materials dual degree at IIT BHU described several drawbacks, including limited domestic scope, and faculty and infrastructure that he rated as average.
Opinion pieces online are blunt, and some are exaggerated, so don't take any single verdict as fact. Only choose materials or metallurgy if you are genuinely interested in the subject and are ready to pursue higher studies in India or abroad, or to look for roles in core industries like steel, manufacturing and research. Check the placement reports of the specific branch at both institutes, the research groups and the opportunities for minors or electives in computing, which can widen your options. If your interest is lukewarm, the branch and college tradeoff deserves a serious second look.

Both are good options, and students are split on this one. The decision usually comes down to whether you value the IIT tag or the proven placement culture of a top NIT.
Those who chose NIT Trichy are firm about it. One alumnus who faced a similar decision between a newer IIT and NIT Trichy says he is glad he took NIT Trichy, pointing to graduates landing offers from well-known tech and finance firms, and argues you should not choose an IIT only for the tag. The reasoning is that the older, larger alumni network and the established placement pipeline help CS students in practice.
The case for IIT Gandhinagar is a flexible curriculum with a good number of electives and interdisciplinary options, stronger research exposure and the IIT brand, which helps for higher studies and for some employers. A newer IIT also tends to have a smaller batch, so you may get more attention from faculty.
My advice is to compare the last two or three years of CS placement reports of both colleges and look at the median package and the range of recruiters, not just the highest offer. Talk to seniors about internships and coding culture. If your priority is jobs and a strong alumni network, NIT Trichy has the edge in most student opinions; if research or a flexible curriculum matters more, look closely at IIT Gandhinagar.
Both IIT Gandhinagar and IIT Ropar belong to the same newer generation of IITs, so any comparison is nuanced, and the best choice often comes down to how each fits you.
Rankings and priority lists you will see online differ from one another, and some are generic, so I wouldn't treat any single list as final. Compare the CSE placement reports and internship results of the past two years for both, since that data is public. Look at the faculty research areas that interest you, the hostel and campus conditions, the location and your comfort with the climate. If you are still undecided, think about whether you prefer a flexible, project-driven curriculum or a more traditional, structured one, and talk to current CSE students at both before you fill your choices.

Both are good choices, so decide on what you want to do after graduation rather than on the institute name alone.
Another point students raise is that ECE graduates are welcome in most IT company hiring, so ECE does not close the software door if you build coding skills alongside it. CSE at a newer IIT, on the other hand, can still be a strong bet if coding is clearly your priority.
Be honest about whether you enjoy programming or circuits. Talk to seniors in both branches, compare recent placement outcomes and pick the one you will be motivated to work hard at.
I could not find mechanical-specific feedback from students, so this comes from how they compare the two institutes generally.
For mechanical, the practical test is what you want after the degree. If research, a smaller class and a good city appeal, Gandhinagar fits. If you prefer a larger mechanical department, core and industry links and a bigger alumni base, look at Dhanbad, but check its location and campus life. Ask seniors from both about mechanical placements and internships.
All three are second-generation IITs, and students are not unanimous on which is best for CSE, so use these opinions as inputs, not verdicts.
A current IIT Ropar undergraduate described the CSE curriculum as well designed, the faculty as knowledgeable and helpful, the student-to-faculty ratio as good, and the labs as modern and spacious. He also said CSE placements there have a strong history, with most students placed on campus. That is a student's account, so check the latest report.
Another student, comparing admission cut-offs, said Gandhinagar has been the most sought after, followed by Ropar, and described Gandhinagar as having a beautiful campus and being mentored by IIT Bombay, but with a coding culture that was still developing at the time.
For Gandhinagar versus top NITs, students are split. Some say the IIT brand, research focus and small intake are advantages, while others feel top NITs are more practical for packages and note that a student quoted a CSE median at Gandhinagar of around 13 to 14 LPA, which another student considered fine in the current job market.
My advice is to compare:
Then weigh location and distance from home. If the numbers are close, the campus where you feel most comfortable and where seniors are supportive is usually the right choice.

If you are certain about chemical engineering and want to work in core fields, a specialised institute can be a better choice than a mid-tier IIT. A person who made a similar choice said ICT Mumbai may suit you better than the newer IITs in that case. That makes sense because ICT is built around chemical and related fields, so the department, labs and industry links are central to the institute and not one department among many.
There is also a frank note on the job market from students:
So my advice is to choose ICT Mumbai if you are firmly committed to chemical engineering and want core industry exposure. Choose IIT Hyderabad or Gandhinagar if you want the IIT name, a broader campus and flexibility to pivot into coding, research or management. Compare the latest placement reports and ask current students in the chemical departments before deciding.
Comments