Master of Business Administration [M.B.A]
Field of Study:
$42,426 /Yr
York University Master of Business Administration is a graduate degree in Toronto, Canada, offered in the accelerated part-time mode over 16 to 20 months. Applicants need a recognised undergraduate degree with a minimum B average in the last two full years. For Indian applicants, use approximately 70% to 79% or CGPA 7.0 to 7.9 on 10 as a planning range. For the September 2027 intake, tuition is unpublished; 2025-26 part-time international tuition was CAD 12,453.11 (INR 8.63 Lakhs) per term, as a prior-cycle reference.
The curriculum combines 33.00 foundation credits, 27.00 elective credits, 15+ specializations and a two-term strategic consulting project with clients. It suits applicants with at least two years of relevant post-degree experience who want a management pivot while retaining a flexible study structure. However, York publishes no international part-time tuition on its current page and asks international students to review immigration rules before choosing part-time study.
- A two-term strategic consulting project connects classroom learning to a client problem.
- The elective structure supports specialization choices across 15+ areas.
- Both September and January entry points are listed for full-time and part-time MBA study.
Current Admission Status
Applications for the September 2027 intake are Not Yet Open. International student deadline: 21 October 2026.
The official deadline page gives a calendar date but no clock time. The portal cutoff controls, so Indian applicants should confirm the submission time before uploading the final application.
Also Check: York University MBA admission
York University MBA Fees and Living Costs 2027
September 2027 international tuition for the accelerated part-time MBA is unpublished on York’s current public fee page. The page publishes a full-time international rate but directs international students to review immigration rules before considering part-time study.
York’s current page states that accelerated part-time students average five terms to completion. The fee table therefore separates the current application fee from a 2025-26 prior-cycle reference and its calculated planning illustration.
| Fee item | CAD amount | INR equivalent | Cycle or status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Part-time international tuition per term | CAD 12,453.11 | INR 8.63 Lakhs | 2025-26 prior-cycle reference |
| Accelerated part-time tuition for five terms | CAD 62,265.55 | INR 43.15 Lakhs | Calculated 2025-26 prior-cycle planning illustration |
| Application fee | CAD 150 | INR 10,394 | Current published fee; non-refundable |
Source: Schulich School of Business tuition and fees page and York Student Financial Services fee schedule.
All INR conversions in the article use a conversion rate of CAD 1 = INR 69.2942 as of 24 August 2026. Rates fluctuate daily, verify before applying.
The prior-cycle per-term figure includes tuition and supplementary fees, while the five-term amount multiplies that published total by York’s accelerated part-time completion average. Do not treat either figure as September 2027 tuition.
Verify the target fee on the official fee page before submitting an application or paying a deposit.
Cost of Living in Toronto for MBA Students
York’s official estimate covers a four-month term and is intended as a full-time budget guide. The following table converts the published off-campus ranges into monthly and calculated 12-month equivalents.
| Expense | Monthly (CAD) | Monthly (INR) | 12-month equivalent (CAD) | 12-month equivalent (INR) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Books and course materials | CAD 187.50 | INR 12,993 | CAD 2,250 | INR 1.56 Lakhs |
| Housing and rent | CAD 1,250 to CAD 2,500 | INR 86,618 to INR 1.73 Lakhs | CAD 15,000 to CAD 30,000 | INR 10.39 Lakhs to INR 20.79 Lakhs |
| Food | CAD 350 to CAD 991.25 | INR 24,253 to INR 68,688 | CAD 4,200 to CAD 11,895 | INR 2.91 Lakhs to INR 8.24 Lakhs |
| Personal expenses | CAD 500 to CAD 625 | INR 34,647 to INR 43,309 | CAD 6,000 to CAD 7,500 | INR 4.16 Lakhs to INR 5.20 Lakhs |
| Local public transportation | CAD 104 to CAD 203 | INR 7,207 to INR 14,067 | CAD 1,248 to CAD 2,436 | INR 86,479 to INR 1.69 Lakhs |
| University Health Insurance Plan (UHIP) | CAD 66 | INR 4,573 | CAD 792 | INR 54,881 |
| Graduate student plan, optional for part-time students | CAD 47 | INR 3,257 | CAD 564 | INR 39,082 |
| Approximate off-campus total | CAD 2,504.50 to CAD 4,619.75 | INR 1.74 Lakhs to INR 3.20 Lakhs | CAD 30,054 to CAD 55,437 | INR 20.83 Lakhs to INR 38.41 Lakhs |
Source: York University living expenses estimate for Toronto; monthly and annual figures are calculated from the official four-month ranges.
The table uses off-campus inputs and includes the graduate student plan as a separate optional line. UHIP is mandatory for international students, while York marks the graduate plan optional for part-time students.
A prior-cycle planning illustration for five accelerated part-time terms uses CAD 62,265.55 (INR 43.15 Lakhs) in tuition. Five living periods cost CAD 50,090 to CAD 92,395 (INR 34.71 Lakhs to INR 64.02 Lakhs), plus CAD 150 (INR 10,394). The calculated all-in range is CAD 112,505.55 to CAD 154,810.55 (INR 77.96 Lakhs to INR 1.07 Crore). Travel, deposits, taxes and other immigration costs are extra because this is not a September 2027 quote.
Read More: Cost of living in Canada
ROI reality: The target-mode tuition is still unpublished, so use the prior-cycle illustration only to test funding capacity. Verify the September 2027 fee before paying a deposit.
York University MBA Admission 2027
Admission requires a recognised undergraduate degree, at least two years of relevant post-degree experience and GMAT (Graduate Management Admission Test) or GRE (Graduate Record Examinations) scores. York does not publish a GMAT or GRE minimum, so the application must show academic readiness, professional direction and evidence across its written and video components.
Both September and January starts are listed for full-time and part-time MBA study. A three-year degree may be considered when the applicant has one additional year of work experience beyond the required minimum.
Academic Eligibility for York University MBA
The academic screen is a B average in the last two full years, supported by relevant experience and a complete application file. The table separates the published requirement from the evidence Indian applicants must prepare.
| Requirement | Official MBA requirement | Indian applicant implication |
|---|---|---|
| Undergraduate degree | Recognised post-secondary degree with a minimum B average in the last two full years. | Use approximately 70% to 79% or CGPA 7.0 to 7.9 on 10 as a planning range; York makes the final equivalency decision. |
| Three-year degree | May be considered with one year of work experience beyond the required minimum. | Document the additional year separately from the two-year baseline. |
| Work experience | At least two years of relevant post-degree full-time work experience or life experience. | Show progression, responsibility and relevance in the resume and essays. |
| GMAT or GRE | Required with acceptable scores on all measures; no minimum score is published. | Submit an official score or a planned test date through the application. |
| Application file | Two written essays, one timed written response, two video essays, a current resume, two references, unofficial transcripts and unofficial GMAT or GRE scores. | Prepare the timed and video components before selecting a round. |
| Interview | Selected applicants may receive a 30-minute virtual interview covering goals, fit, teamwork, leadership, initiative, communication, adaptability and problem solving. | Use examples that connect career goals to the MBA’s consulting and specialization structure. |
| Transcript evaluation | Schulich assesses non-Canadian transcripts and does not accept external evaluations such as WES (World Education Services). | Provide English originals or accepted translations rather than commissioning an external evaluation. |
The B average is a screening threshold rather than a published conversion table. The approximate Indian range is only a planning guide, while York decides equivalency from the submitted transcripts.
The two-year experience rule matters for this accelerated route because applicants must explain how they will manage post-degree work alongside a compressed MBA schedule.
Tests and English Language Proficiency for York University MBA
IELTS (International English Language Testing System) or TOEFL (Test of English as a Foreign Language) is required when prior university study does not meet York’s English-language exemption. York publishes different TOEFL scales by test date, so Indian applicants must use the row matching their planned test.
| Test or route | Current official requirement | Planning implication |
|---|---|---|
| IELTS Academic | Overall 7.0 with a minimum 6.5 on each dimension. | Plan for every component because a single lower dimension misses the published threshold. |
| TOEFL tests before 21 January 2026 | 100 iBT with a minimum 23 on each dimension. | Use only for a test date covered by York’s stated policy. |
| TOEFL tests after 21 January 2026 | 5 iBT with a minimum 4.5 on each dimension. | Do not self-convert this scale to the older 0 to 120 scale. |
| English-language exemption | At least two years of full-time study at an accredited university in a country or institution where English is an official language. | Prepare proof of the qualifying study period before relying on the exemption. |
- Use IELTS Academic 7.0 overall with no band below 6.5 as the clearest published route for this application.
- The TOEFL policy changes by test date, so attach the correct scale to the planned test date.
- Applicants relying on English-medium university study should verify the exemption evidence before omitting an English test.
MBA Class Profile Context
The latest official employment report gives a useful benchmark, but it covers the MBA Class of 2024 full-time final-term cohort, not the accelerated part-time route.
| Class profile measure | Reported result | Scope |
|---|---|---|
| Average age | 27 | MBA Class of 2024 |
| Average work experience | 5 years | MBA Class of 2024 |
| Average GMAT | 661 | MBA Class of 2024 |
| GMAT range | 530 to 780 | MBA Class of 2024 |
| Average GPA (Grade Point Average) | 7.0, equivalent to A- | MBA Class of 2024; not an admission cutoff |
| Graduating class size | 235 | MBA Class of 2024 |
| International students | 64% | MBA Class of 2024 |
| Female students | 33% | MBA Class of 2024 |
The profile can guide preparation but cannot establish a cutoff or part-time admission probability. Use the published B average and two-year experience rule as the hard screen, then strengthen the rest of the file.
Source: Schulich MBA admissions requirements and the 2024 MBA employment report.
Read More: York University MBA programs
Student perspective
Multiple MBA entries describe case discussions and group work as useful but academically demanding alongside employment. Other entries say career guidance and networking require substantial initiative. Test whether the accelerated workload leaves time for job-search activity by reading the student reviews.
These comments are anecdotal and do not replace official York University data.
Tip for Indian students: Meet the B-average and two-year experience thresholds first, then choose an English test scale and submit by Round 2. Do not treat the full-time class profile as an accelerated part-time admission target.
York University MBA Application 2027
September 2027 is the next applicant-accessible international intake, with three published international rounds. Round 3 is the final international deadline, while Rounds 4 and 5 are reserved for domestic applicants.
York usually releases decisions 6 to 8 weeks after a deadline, but the current MBA page publishes no exact decision dates or clock times. The university’s calendar date controls, so the portal should be checked when each round opens.
September 2027 international deadlines are listed below; every date is a calendar date because York publishes no time-zone cutoff for these rounds.
| Round | International application deadline | Application implication |
|---|---|---|
| Round 1 | 21 October 2026 | Earliest published review round for September 2027. |
| Round 2 | 20 January 2027 | Recommended international round for funding and study-permit timing. |
| Round 3 | 3 March 2027 | Final published international deadline. |
January entry is offered for part-time MBA study, but no January 2028 international round dates appear on the current MBA deadline page after checking the published admissions surfaces.
York University MBA Application Steps
The application combines written work, video responses, references, academic records and a standardised test. Applicants can submit before a planned GMAT, GRE or English test, then provide the score within York’s stated post-deadline recommendation.
- Prepare two written essays, one timed written response and two video essays before choosing a round.
- Upload an up-to-date resume, two references and unofficial transcripts with the online application.
- Enter the planned GMAT, GRE or English-test date when the score is not available at submission.
- Pay the current non-refundable application fee of CAD 150 (INR 10,394) by credit card and verify the amount when the form opens.
Schulich assesses non-Canadian transcripts from the submitted records and accepts originals in English or accepted translations. External evaluations are not accepted, so an Indian applicant should not add a separate WES report.
Round 2 on 20 January 2027 is the practical target for applicants who need funding and study-permit processing time. York strongly encourages international candidates to apply by Round 2 because most financial aid may be distributed later.
Use Round 2 as the working deadline even when Round 3 remains available. A complete application submitted by Round 2 gives the file more time for review, interview scheduling and immigration preparation.
Application tip: Use Round 2 as the target because York links that round to funding and study-permit timing. Submit a complete file even when a planned score will follow within York’s four-week recommendation.
York University MBA Scholarships 2027
International MBA applicants are automatically considered for merit-based entrance awards when they submit the admission application. Need-based or discretionary awards may require a separate process after shortlisting.
The current awards page lists options open to international students in any mode, but it does not publish September 2027-specific deadlines. These are current published opportunities, not guaranteed target-cycle awards.
Several headline international MBA awards are marked full-time on the live page. Indian applicants choosing the accelerated part-time route should not assume those full-time awards apply.
| Award | CAD value | INR equivalent | Eligibility and route |
|---|---|---|---|
| John Belyea (MBA ’89) Award | CAD 7,500 | INR 5.20 Lakhs | Incoming MBA, any visa or status and any mode; minimum GPA 6.0 or B+; positive impact beyond the classroom. |
| Access to Success Fellowship | CAD 5,000 | INR 3.46 Lakhs | Incoming MBA, any visa or status and any mode; identify a disability; minimum cumulative GPA 4.0 or B-; up to three awards. |
| Jack Leitch Award in Entrepreneurial Thinking | Value varies | Not applicable | Incoming MBA, any visa or status and any mode; entrepreneurship or innovation evidence; cover letter and resume required. |
| Schulich Entrance Award of Merit | Value varies | Not applicable | Entrance award for master’s-level applicants, any visa or status and any mode; minimum cumulative GPA 5.0 or B. |
| Schulich International Grant | Value varies | Not applicable | International incoming or continuing students, any mode; no separate application; selection considers academic achievement. |
| Graduating Class 1994 Part-Time MBA Scholarship | Value varies | Not applicable | Continuing part-time MBA students in the final semester; minimum GPA 6.0 or B+ and financial need. |
The John Belyea and Access to Success awards publish fixed values, while the other listed awards vary. Do not subtract a value-varies award from the prior-cycle budget until York confirms the amount and eligibility.
The part-time scholarship for the final semester is a later-stage funding option rather than an entrance payment source. An applicant must therefore plan the initial deposit and early terms without assuming that award.
- Submit the admission application by Round 2 because York links early international applications with scholarship and financial-aid timing.
- Use the Access to Success route only when disability eligibility and the minimum GPA evidence can be documented.
- Treat value-varies awards as funding upside rather than a budget input until the award notice states the amount.
Also Check: York University scholarships
Scholarship reality: The clearest fixed entrance values are CAD 7,500 (INR 5.20 Lakhs) and CAD 5,000 (INR 3.46 Lakhs). Apply by Round 2 and retain a funding plan that works without an award.
York University MBA Salary 2027
The latest official employment report records 80% of actively seeking graduates with an offer within three months and 91% within six months. The figures cover the MBA Class of 2024 full-time final-term cohort, not the accelerated part-time route.
Average base salary and total compensation are reported for graduates employed within three months who supplied compensation data. These are gross Canadian figures, so they cannot be treated as take-home pay or guaranteed outcomes.
| Compensation measure | CAD result | INR equivalent | Evidence scope |
|---|---|---|---|
| Average base salary | CAD 90,643 | INR 62.81 Lakhs | MBA Class of 2024; employed within three months and reported compensation |
| Average total compensation | CAD 95,578 | INR 66.23 Lakhs | MBA Class of 2024; employed within three months and reported compensation |
| Average signing bonus | CAD 9,889 | INR 6.85 Lakhs | MBA Class of 2024; reported compensation |
Source: Schulich MBA Employment Report 2024; salary figures are reported averages.
Employment Mix in MBA Class of 2024
The report’s industry mix shows where graduates worked, while its function mix shows the roles reported. These shares describe the full-time 2024 cohort and do not establish employer preference for part-time students.
| Dimension | Category | Reported share | Scope |
|---|---|---|---|
| Industry | Financial Services | 27% | MBA Class of 2024 |
| Industry | Law | 17% | MBA Class of 2024 |
| Industry | Technology | 11% | MBA Class of 2024 |
| Industry | Consulting | 10% | MBA Class of 2024 |
| Industry | Consumer Packaged Goods | 6% | MBA Class of 2024 |
| Function | General Management | 24% | MBA Class of 2024 |
| Function | Legal Services | 16% | MBA Class of 2024 |
| Function | Consulting | 16% | MBA Class of 2024 |
| Function | Finance and Accounting | 13% | MBA Class of 2024 |
| Function | Marketing and Sales | 13% | MBA Class of 2024 |
The report records 284 recruitment events accessible to MBA students and 254 companies posting MBA-level jobs. It also records 110 companies hiring members of the MBA Class of 2024, which shows employer presence without proving a typical result.
ROI for an Indian Applicant
The cost decision remains conditional because September 2027 part-time international tuition is unpublished. The 2025-26 five-term tuition illustration was CAD 62,265.55 (INR 43.15 Lakhs). Five living periods were CAD 50,090 to CAD 92,395 (INR 34.71 Lakhs to INR 64.02 Lakhs).
- The published cost is prior-cycle planning evidence, so obtain the target fee before committing a deposit or loan.
- The 91% six-month offer rate belongs to the full-time final-term cohort, so do not forecast the same result for accelerated part-time study.
- Average base salary was CAD 90,643 (INR 62.81 Lakhs) before taxes, so model gross Canadian pay rather than take-home pay.
- Part-time study may affect study-permit and post-graduation work eligibility, so obtain written immigration guidance before choosing this route.
- For an India-return plan, use the Canadian outcomes as context and build a separate rupee income case without a calculated payback period.
Take-home pay varies with province, payroll deductions and compensation mix. Use the Canada Revenue Agency payroll deductions calculator before modelling net income.
Read More: York University MBA placements
ROI reality: The report supports a school-level career signal, not a part-time outcome guarantee. Confirm the target fee and immigration route before treating Canadian salary evidence as a financing assumption.
Canada Visa for York University MBA Students 2027
A Canadian study permit is not automatic for this accelerated part-time route, and post-study work eligibility cannot be promised. A PGWP (Post-Graduation Work Permit) allows eligible graduates to work after study. A master’s programme of at least eight months may qualify for up to three years, but full-time status is required each semester except the final one. Canada has no single federal skilled-worker salary threshold or fixed permanent-residence timeline.
- Current figures are permit CAD 150 (INR 10,394), biometrics CAD 85 (INR 5,890) and living funds CAD 22,895 (INR 15.86 Lakhs) outside Quebec.
- York’s part-time warning makes written confirmation of study-permit eligibility a prerequisite before paying a deposit.
- The accelerated part-time route cannot be promised a PGWP, so verify the current PGWP eligibility rules before enrolment.
- A spouse or common-law partner may qualify for an open work permit if the student studies in a master’s programme of at least 16 months, subject to current rules.
The living-funds figure excludes tuition and transport. The Canadian Experience Class requires 1,560 hours of paid authorised work in eligible TEER (Training, Education, Experience and Responsibilities) 0 to 3 roles within three years. That route is score-based after qualifying work, so it does not provide a guaranteed permanent-residence timeline.
Check Out: York University accommodation options
Visa reality: The accelerated part-time mode is the main immigration risk because York does not publish a blanket part-time study-permit or PGWP guarantee. Obtain written confirmation before using the prior-cycle budget or paying a deposit.
York University MBA Ranking 2027
Schulich’s official rankings page places the school in the top 100 of the 2026 QS (Quacquarelli Symonds) Global MBA Ranking. The associated QS listing places the full-time MBA at #=99 globally, after a 2025 position in the #101 to 110 band.
This is a full-time MBA ranking rather than an accelerated part-time ranking. It can provide school-level context, but it does not establish part-time placement probability or salary.
| Ranking edition | Position | Scope |
|---|---|---|
| QS Global MBA Ranking 2026 | #=99 | Full-time MBA, global |
| QS Global MBA Ranking 2025 | #101 to 110 | Full-time MBA, global |
Source: Schulich School of Business rankings page and QS Global MBA listing.
Honest take: The 2026 ranking is relevant to the school and full-time MBA, not proof of outcomes for this part-time route. Give greater weight to the visa, fee and cohort-scope checks before applying.
York University’s accelerated part-time MBA fits an experienced applicant who wants a Toronto management degree, specialization choice and a client-facing strategy project. The key tradeoff is that September 2027 international part-time tuition is unpublished and visa or PGWP treatment must be verified before committing. MBA Class of 2024 outcomes provide useful school-level context, but they describe graduates with full-time status in their final term rather than this exact route. Start with the Round 2 20 January 2027 deadline, confirm part-time study-permit eligibility in writing and then submit a funding-backed application.
York University MBA FAQs
Ques. Is York University’s accelerated part-time MBA suitable for an Indian applicant who needs a Canadian study permit?
Ans. It may be suitable academically because the MBA accepts applicants with a recognised degree and two years of relevant experience. However, York tells international students to review immigration rules before considering part-time study. Obtain written confirmation of study-permit and post-study-work eligibility before paying a deposit.
Ques. What GMAT or GRE score should an Indian applicant target for the York University MBA?
Ans. York requires GMAT or GRE scores but publishes no minimum. The MBA Class of 2024 full-time final-term cohort reported average GMAT 661 with a range of 530 to 780. Treat this as context, not a part-time target.
Ques. What is the total cost of the York University accelerated part-time MBA?
Ans. September 2027 international tuition is unpublished. The 2025-26 prior-cycle reference was CAD 12,453.11 (INR 8.63 Lakhs) per term, with five terms calculated at CAD 62,265.55 (INR 43.15 Lakhs). Add Toronto living costs separately. The prior-cycle all-in illustration is CAD 112,505.55 to CAD 154,810.55 (INR 77.96 Lakhs to INR 1.07 Crore). Travel and immigration costs are extra.
Ques. Which scholarships can part-time international MBA applicants pursue?
Ans. The live awards page lists John Belyea at CAD 7,500 (INR 5.20 Lakhs) and Access to Success at CAD 5,000 (INR 3.46 Lakhs). It also lists value-varies awards. Apply by Round 2 and do not budget an award until York confirms it.
Ques. Can the York University MBA guarantee a Canadian job, PGWP or permanent residence?
Ans. No. The employment report’s 80% three-month and 91% six-month offer rates cover full-time final-term MBA Class of 2024 graduates, not this route. PGWP eligibility depends on programme and full-time status rules. Permanent residence requires a separate qualifying route such as Canadian Experience Class work experience and has no fixed timeline.
Tuition Fees
| Year | 1st Year Fees |
|---|---|
| Tuition Fees | $42426 (CAD 58925) |
Other Expenses
| Head | Avg Cost Per Year |
|---|---|
| Housing | $3835 (CAD 5326) |
| Food | $2835 (CAD 3937) |
Scores Required
3 / 4
Minimum gpa
GPA
Required Document List
Following Documents are required to attend this program:
- Statement of Purpose: An essay or other written statement written by the student.
- Resume/CV: Outline of academic achievements and/or awards, publications, relevant work, and/or volunteer experience.
- Academic Documents: Submit copies of official transcripts from post-secondary institutions attended.
- Sample of written work: Student has to write something interesting as their sample essay in the application form.
- Statement of Interest: Reasons or intentions for pursuing studies in this program, including a description of prior experience.
- Two confidential letters of recommendation: Referees (Teachers, guidance counselors, or Professors) should comment on academics and that references should submit along with the application system.
- Proof that students have enough money to support themselves during their stay in Canada.
- Letters of reference or any other documents the visa office tell students to bring.


Do you think the Rankings are wrong ? Report Here
TOP Scholarships
| Scholarship name | Award amount | Eligibility |
|---|---|---|
| York International Merit Award | $10,000 | Final admission average of 80% - 84.9% |
| York International Entrance Award | $5,000 | Final admission average of 75% - 79.9% |
Key Resources for Your Study Abroad Journey
Course Guides
Best Post-Graduate Courses in Canada in 2025
Executive MBA in Canada: Check Top Colleges and Fees
Masters in Canada: Fees 2024, Top Colleges, Placements & Salaries
Masters in Management in Canada: Deadlines, Fees, Jobs, and Salary
Scholarship Grants & Financial Aids
| Name | Scholarship Per Student | Level of Study | Type | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Golden Key Graduate Scholar Award | Scholarship per student$ 1,080/Yr$1,500 | Level Of StudyMaster | TypeMerit-Based | |
| Axol Science Scholarship | Scholarship per student$ 1,440/Yr$2,000 | Level Of StudyBachelor | TypeCompany-Sponsored | |
| Business Administration Scholarships | Scholarship per studentVariable Amount | Level Of StudyBachelor | TypeMerit-Based | |
| University of Montreal Scholarships | Scholarship per studentVariable Amount | Level Of StudyBachelor | TypeCollege-Specific | |
| VueVille Future Technology Scholarship | Scholarship per student$ 720/Yr$1,000 | Level Of StudyBachelor | TypeMerit-Based | |
| Go Clean Scholarship | Scholarship per student$ 2,520/Yr$3,500 | Level Of StudyBachelor | TypeMerit-Based |

















Comments