There is no single right answer, which is why students keep debating it. One side says NMIMS Mumbai is easily a top-tier school with strong recruiter recognition. The other says its standing has slipped since admissions became easier and that the IIM tag at Udaipur now carries comparable value.
Here's the practical split from students who have looked at both:
Recruiters already sort colleges into buckets, so the tag matters less at the new IIMs than at older ones.
Don't choose based on someone else's tier list. Ask for batch-wise placement reports, check the number of unplaced students and the median salary for your target function, and talk to current students about the complaints they have. Then weigh fees against the likely outcome.
This is a long-running debate, and students are split on it. Some call NMIMS Mumbai a tier-one school and say it has no equal among the newer IIMs, while others dispute that label, pointing to a more relaxed admission process for the main campus. Either way, the two are often compared, so it's a valid dilemma.
The most useful advice from students depends on your target. For marketing, many say NMIMS still has a hold that newer IIMs haven't matched, and recruiters know the name well. They also say the top slice of the batch gets very good roles, but the bottom half has a harder time. For an average profile, the IIM tag at Udaipur or Trichy may be the safer route.
Another view is that new IIMs are catching up quickly and could be on par within a few years. So decide by your profile and your goal:
Compare the latest placement reports for both before paying the fee.
There is no single right answer, which is why students keep debating it. One side says NMIMS Mumbai is easily a top-tier school with strong recruiter recognition. The other says its standing has slipped since admissions became easier and that the IIM tag at Udaipur now carries comparable value.
Here's the practical split from students who have looked at both:
Recruiters already sort colleges into buckets, so the tag matters less at the new IIMs than at older ones.
Don't choose based on someone else's tier list. Ask for batch-wise placement reports, check the number of unplaced students and the median salary for your target function, and talk to current students about the complaints they have. Then weigh fees against the likely outcome.
This is a long-running debate, and students are split on it. Some call NMIMS Mumbai a tier-one school and say it has no equal among the newer IIMs, while others dispute that label, pointing to a more relaxed admission process for the main campus. Either way, the two are often compared, so it's a valid dilemma.
The most useful advice from students depends on your target. For marketing, many say NMIMS still has a hold that newer IIMs haven't matched, and recruiters know the name well. They also say the top slice of the batch gets very good roles, but the bottom half has a harder time. For an average profile, the IIM tag at Udaipur or Trichy may be the safer route.
Another view is that new IIMs are catching up quickly and could be on par within a few years. So decide by your profile and your goal:
Compare the latest placement reports for both before paying the fee.
There is no single right answer, which is why students keep debating it. One side says NMIMS Mumbai is easily a top-tier school with strong recruiter recognition. The other says its standing has slipped since admissions became easier and that the IIM tag at Udaipur now carries comparable value.
Here's the practical split from students who have looked at both:
Recruiters already sort colleges into buckets, so the tag matters less at the new IIMs than at older ones.
Don't choose based on someone else's tier list. Ask for batch-wise placement reports, check the number of unplaced students and the median salary for your target function, and talk to current students about the complaints they have. Then weigh fees against the likely outcome.