Think of this as brand versus branch, and be honest about what you want to do after graduation. IIT Bombay Metallurgy and NIT Surathkal CSE are very different bets.
Students who compare IITs with NIT Surathkal often prefer NIT Surathkal CSE if you don't care much about the IIT tag, calling it a safer choice for software careers. They also advise looking at the placement statistics yourself, since the numbers are easy to find on the official pages. A related piece of advice is that if you choose a weaker branch at an IIT, you will need to put in extra effort to build coding and data skills, since materials-based branches have fewer direct software routes.
IIT Bombay gives you a top brand, a very strong alumni network and exposure to research, consulting and finance, which all remain open to students from any branch. But metallurgy has a narrower core industry, and many graduates in such branches pivot into other fields or do higher studies.
My advice is this. If you are sure about software, NIT Surathkal CSE is the safer and more direct path. If you are open to core, research, higher studies, or a non-core path such as consulting and management, and you are willing to work to build extra skills, IIT Bombay can open more doors long term. Ask seniors in both programmes what their classmates do after graduation.
Choosing a branch over a college and vice versa is a big dilemma for many engineering aspirants. I personally feel one should give preference to branch over college because the college stays with you just for 4 years but the branch determines your career. NIT Surathkal CSE is a highly regarded program and recently its infrastructure has been improved to meet industry needs. Here are some core reasons to prefer it over IIT Bombay Metallurgy.
Ultimately, it’s up to you to decide if you want to prioritize the branch or the college.