This is really a question about branch versus institute. Students who have spent time at NITK Surathkal talk about the strength of its peer group, active technical communities and long alumni history. A newer IIT is still building those, and one student who knew friends at a newer IIT said the lack of seniors who had already done well was noticeable.
On the other side, you'd be at an IIT, and the EE curriculum there follows IIT standards. But some posts raise concerns about placement outcomes at IIT Dharwad across branches, and a few students even say they'd pick NITK ahead of it. These are individual opinions and not official data, so don't treat them as settled.
If you're fine with software or IT roles and want the stronger campus ecosystem, NITK CSE is the safer choice for most students who responded. If you're genuinely drawn to electrical, power or electronics and are comfortable with a smaller, newer campus, EE at Dharwad is a valid choice. Before you lock, compare recent placement reports for EE at Dharwad against CSE at NITK, and speak to current students on both campuses about internships and labs.
Students lean towards NITK Surathkal here, but the right call depends on your branch interest. A student who has spent time at NITK says that much of the learning in college comes from peers, seniors, technical communities and alumni, and that NITK batches have built a strong record of technical achievements that sets the pace for newer batches. A new IIT is still building such an ecosystem.
Some forum posts go further and say established NITs are well ahead of newer IITs in infrastructure, faculty, credibility and alumni network, especially for core disciplines. Others point to negative news about placements at IIT Dharwad, though such claims should be checked against the institute's own recent reports, since placements at new campuses can change a lot from batch to batch.
The two choices also differ in branch. CSE at NITK is a computing seat in an established college, while EE at IIT Dharwad is a core branch at a young IIT.
Talk to seniors from both, and read the latest placement reports before deciding.
Rather than choosing between institutes, choose the branch you are inclined towards. Determining your future prospects is an indispensable factor when choosing your college. You need to find out what you are willing to do after getting your degree; pursuing higher studies or getting employed.
Had I been in your place, I would have chosen NIT Surathkal because of the branch CSE you are getting. In this high-tech era, CSE is in full bloom and is one of the most coveted branches. Someone who is getting CSE at an NIT should never give that chance up for any other branch that too at a new IIT.
Here is why one should go for NIT Surathkal
The following points prove enough that NITK Surathkal CSE is better than IIT Dhanbad EE. In fact, I would have chosen IIT Dhanwad CSE over electrical or other core branches at old IITs. however, my answer is not directed towards someone who has a particular interest in Electrical, for them IIT EE is the best.
IIT Dharwad is a relatively newly established institute and the first batch of engineering graduates in 2020 only, it is yet to be ranked by NIRF. While NITK Surathkal is one of the oldest NITs of the country and is ranked 33rd by NIRF for Engineering.
The Table given below briefly compares factors like seat intake and fees.
|
Category |
IIT Dharwad-EE |
NITK-CSE |
|
Total Fees |
8.6 lakhs |
5.5 lakhs |
|
Cut Off |
JEE Advanced: 2500-4000 |
JEE Main: 1500-2500 |
|
Seat intake |
40 |
46 |
Curriculum
IIT Dharwad
NITK
Placement
NITK
IIT Dharwad
Campus
NIT Surathkal or NITK is one of the premier engineering institutes of the country and has a strong alumni network and industry connect. Training sessions are even organised by industry giants like IBM, CoCubes. IIT Dharwad being a new institute needs time and resources to make its mark. Apart from this, computer science is the most sought after skill-set at present and attracts lucrative offers. Hence, students should make an informed choice according to their discretion.