DNB CET Counselling 2027 is the centralised online seat allocation process conducted by the National Board of Examinations in Medical Sciences (NBEMS) for admission to DNB Post Diploma programs. Approximately 1,000+ seats across 600+ NBEMS-accredited hospitals covering 14 broad specialties are filled through four rounds — three online and one offline mop-up — based purely on merit rank and locked preferences.
- Counselling conducting body: NBEMS (National Board of Examinations in Medical Sciences)
- Official counselling portal: counseling.nbe.edu.in
- Programs covered: DNB Post Diploma broad specialty programs (14 specialties)
- Total rounds: Round 1, Round 2, Round 3 (online) + Offline Mop-Up Round
- Counselling registration fee: ₹2,500 (flat fee, all categories — based on 2026 cycle)
- 2027 counselling expected to begin: July 2027 (after DNB CET 2027 result)
What is DNB CET Counselling 2027?
DNB CET — formally the Diplomate of National Board Post Diploma Centralized Entrance Test (DNB PDCET) — is the national-level entrance test for DNB Post Diploma programs, and counselling is the process by which NBEMS assigns seats in accredited hospitals based on merit rank and preference. The counselling is fully online for three rounds, with a fourth offline mop-up round to fill any remaining seats.
NBEMS fills seats in approximately 600+ recognised hospitals across India covering 14 broad specialties: Anaesthesiology, Child Health, ENT, Family Medicine, General Medicine, General Surgery, Gynaecology and Obstetrics, Ophthalmology, Orthopaedic Surgery, Paediatrics, Psychiatry, Radiology, Respiratory Medicine, and Skin and VD. Registering for counselling is mandatory — your exam rank alone does not guarantee a seat.
The 2027 counselling schedule has not been released as of September 2026. NBEMS publishes the schedule after the DNB CET 2027 result is declared. Based on the 2026 cycle — exam held April 12, result declared May 14, Round 1 registration opened July 2 — the 2027 counselling is expected to begin in July 2027. NBEMS releases the schedule round-by-round on counseling.nbe.edu.in rather than publishing all four rounds at once.
DNB CET 2027 Counselling Important Dates
All dates below are projected based on the 2026 cycle. The official 2027 schedule will be published on counseling.nbe.edu.in after the result declaration — expected around May 2027.
| Event | Expected Date (2027) | Status |
|---|---|---|
| DNB CET 2027 Exam | April 2027 | Upcoming |
| DNB CET 2027 Result Declaration | May 2027 | Upcoming |
| Individual Scorecards Available on Portal | May / June 2027 | Upcoming |
| Round 1 — Counselling Registration Opens | 1st week of July 2027 | Upcoming |
| Round 1 — Choice Filling Window Closes | 1st week of July 2027 | Upcoming |
| Round 1 — Seat Allotment Result | 2nd week of July 2027 | Upcoming |
| Round 1 — Reporting to Allotted Hospital | July / August 2027 | Upcoming |
| Round 2 — Choice Filling and Allotment | August 2027 | Upcoming |
| Round 3 — Choice Filling and Allotment | August / September 2027 | Upcoming |
| Offline Mop-Up Round (if vacant seats remain) | September / October 2027 | Upcoming |
Note: All 2027 dates are expected/projected. NBEMS releases round-wise schedules progressively — not all at once. Monitor counseling.nbe.edu.in and natboard.edu.in from May 2027 onwards for official confirmed dates.
DNB CET Counselling Eligibility Criteria 2027
You must satisfy all the conditions below to register for DNB CET 2027 counselling. A qualifying rank is necessary but not sufficient — each condition is independently verified at document upload and again at hospital reporting.
- Valid DNB CET 2027 rank: You must have qualified DNB CET 2027 and hold a merit rank. Students without a valid rank from the 2027 cycle cannot register.
- MBBS degree: You must hold an MBBS degree from a medical institution recognised by the National Medical Commission (NMC/erstwhile MCI).
- Post Graduate Diploma qualification: You must have passed the final examination for a PG Diploma in the eligible broad specialty from a recognised Indian university. Based on the 2026 bulletin, the result must have been declared on or before May 31 of the admission year — the exact 2027 cutoff date will be specified in the official NBEMS information bulletin.
- Permanent MCI/NMC or State Medical Council registration: You must hold a valid permanent registration certificate for your MBBS qualification from MCI/NMC or a recognised State Medical Council at the time of applying.
- Completed 12-month rotating internship: Your internship must be from a hospital/institution recognised by NMC/MCI.
- Foreign Medical Graduates: Must have cleared FMGE (Foreign Medical Graduates Examination) or NExT and hold valid NMC permanent registration. The diploma qualification from a foreign institution must be from a university recognised by NMC.
- Age limit: NBEMS does not prescribe an upper age limit for DNB Post Diploma programs — confirm any amendment with the official 2027 notification.
Note: Eligibility conditions — including the diploma-pass cutoff date — are published in the NBEMS DNB CET 2027 Information Bulletin. Always verify against the official bulletin at nbe.edu.in before registering for counselling.
Reservation of Quotas for DNB CET Counselling 2027
NBEMS applies Government of India reservation norms to seats in government-funded hospitals. The majority of DNB Post Diploma seats are in private and charitable hospitals, where reservation does not apply and all students compete on open merit. The table below outlines both frameworks:
| Category | Reservation Percentage | Applicable Seat Type |
|---|---|---|
| Unreserved / General (UR) | Open merit | All hospital types |
| Scheduled Caste (SC) | 15% | Government hospital seats only |
| Scheduled Tribe (ST) | 7.5% | Government hospital seats only |
| Other Backward Classes – Non-Creamy Layer (OBC-NCL) | 27% | Government hospital seats only |
| Economically Weaker Sections (EWS) | 10% | Government hospital seats only |
| Persons with Benchmark Disability (PwBD) | 5% horizontal (across all categories) | Government hospital seats only |
| Private / Charitable Hospital DNB Seats | No statutory reservation — open merit only | All categories compete equally |
Because most seats in the DNB CET seat matrix are in private or charitable hospitals, general-category students have access to the widest pool. Government hospital DNB seats are comparatively fewer but carry statutory reservation benefits for SC, ST, OBC-NCL, EWS, and PwBD students. The practical implication: even if your rank falls in a reserved category cutoff range, the majority of available seats are open merit private hospital seats where that rank may still be competitive.
Note: OBC-NCL certificates must be issued under the Central Government’s OBC list — State OBC lists are not valid for NBEMS central counselling. EWS certificates must be from the current financial year. Category certificate requirements are detailed in the NBEMS 2027 information bulletin.
How to Apply for DNB CET Counselling 2027?
DNB CET 2027 counselling registration takes place entirely online at counseling.nbe.edu.in. NBEMS requires a single registration that covers all rounds — you do not re-register for Round 2 or Round 3. Keep your login credentials safe from the moment of registration. Registering for counselling is mandatory — your exam rank alone does not guarantee a seat.
Step 1: Online Registration
Visit counseling.nbe.edu.in when registration opens (expected 1st week of July 2027) and navigate to "DNB PDCET 2027 Counselling." Register using your DNB CET 2027 Roll Number, date of birth, and the email ID used during exam registration. NBEMS sends login credentials (User ID and temporary password) to your registered email and mobile. These credentials are valid for all four rounds — store them securely. Registration is a one-time step; you do not re-register in subsequent rounds.
Step 2: Registration Fee Payment
After logging in, the portal directs you to pay the non-refundable counselling registration fee (₹2,500 expected for 2027, flat across all categories, based on the 2026 cycle). Payment is via Net Banking, Credit Card, Debit Card, or UPI. A fee payment confirmation slip is generated immediately — download and save it. Without completed payment, the portal blocks access to choice filling. This fee is not refunded under any circumstance: allotment, non-allotment, or withdrawal.
Step 3: Choice Filling
After fee payment, the choice filling window opens. Browse the live seat matrix filtered by specialty, state, and hospital type. Add hospital–specialty combinations to your preference list and arrange them in priority order — rank 1 is your top choice. You can add, remove, and reorder choices multiple times before the deadline. Fill at least 15–20 choices to maximise your chances across all rounds. On the closing date, lock your choices before the cut-off time — late locking is not allowed.
Step 4: Seat Allotment Result
After the choice filling window closes, NBEMS processes the allotment using merit rank and locked preferences. The round-wise result is published on the portal — log in to check your status. If allotted a seat, you must respond within the deadline: choose Freeze, Upgrade, or Withdraw, and pay the first-year course fee to confirm. Students not allotted any seat in one round are automatically eligible for the next round; their original locked preferences carry forward unless modified during the next window.
Step 5: Reporting to Allotted Hospital
After confirming your allotment and paying the course fee, download the official allotment letter from the portal and report to the hospital within the stated deadline. All original documents (listed in the Documents Required section) plus two sets of self-attested photocopies are required at this step. The hospital verifies your documents and completes your formal enrollment in the DNB Post Diploma program. Failure to report by the deadline leads to automatic seat cancellation and forfeiture of fees.
How to Lock Choices for DNB CET Counselling 2027
Choice locking is the final action in the choice filling process. Once locked, no further modifications are possible for that round. The allotment algorithm runs on your locked list — so the order matters as much as the quantity of choices.
Step 1: Log In to the Counselling Portal
- Go to counseling.nbe.edu.in and log in with your User ID and password.
- Select "DNB PDCET 2027 Counselling" and click on "Choice Filling."
Step 2: Build Your Preference List
- Use the specialty, state, and hospital-type filters to browse the available seat matrix.
- Click "Add" against each hospital–specialty combination you want to include.
- Add at least 15–20 entries covering varied hospitals and locations for maximum coverage.
Step 3: Arrange in Priority Order
- Drag entries to arrange them in preference order — your most-wanted option at the top (rank 1).
- Consider specialty demand, hospital reputation, city/location, stipend (for government seats), and course fee (for private seats).
Step 4: Review and Lock
- Review your complete list one final time — additions, order, and specialty details.
- Click "Lock Choices" and confirm at the pop-up prompt.
- Download and save the choice confirmation PDF generated after locking.
If you do not lock manually before the deadline, the portal auto-locks your saved choices at the closing time. Always lock yourself rather than relying on auto-lock — a last-minute connectivity issue can leave your list in a partially edited state when auto-lock triggers.
| Action | Before Locking | After Locking |
|---|---|---|
| Add new hospital / specialty to list | Allowed | Not allowed |
| Remove a choice from the list | Allowed | Not allowed |
| Reorder preferences | Allowed | Not allowed |
| View your locked preference list | Allowed | Allowed |
| Download choice confirmation PDF | Allowed | Allowed |
DNB CET Counselling Documents Required 2027
NBEMS requires digital copies of key documents at the time of online registration. The complete set of originals — plus two self-attested photocopies of each — must be presented in person at the allotted hospital during reporting. A missing document at either stage can delay or cancel your enrollment.
- MBBS Degree Certificate — original, from a NMC/MCI-recognised university
- MBBS Mark Sheets — all professional examination mark sheets (Parts I, II, and III)
- Post Graduate Diploma Pass Certificate / Provisional Pass Certificate — in the eligible broad specialty; must confirm that the result was declared on or before the NBEMS-specified cutoff date
- Permanent Registration Certificate — issued by MCI/NMC or State Medical Council for MBBS qualification
- Internship Completion Certificate — from a NMC/MCI-recognised hospital or institution
- DNB CET 2027 Admit Card — downloaded from the NBEMS exam portal
- DNB CET 2027 Score Card / Rank Letter — from the official NBEMS result portal
- DNB CET 2027 Allotment Letter — downloaded from counseling.nbe.edu.in after seat confirmation (for hospital reporting)
- Identity Proof — Aadhaar Card, Passport, Voter ID, or Driving Licence
- Category Certificate — SC/ST/OBC-NCL/EWS certificate issued by a competent authority; OBC-NCL must be from the Central List and issued within the current financial year; EWS must also be from the current financial year
- PwBD Certificate — issued by a government-notified medical authority or disability board (if applicable)
- FMGE / NExT Pass Certificate and NMC Registration — for foreign medical graduates only
- Passport-size photographs — 6 to 10 recent copies
- Counselling registration fee payment receipt — proof of ₹2,500 payment from the counselling portal
- Course fee payment receipt — confirmation that the first-year course fee has been paid to confirm allotment
Note: The authoritative checklist is published in the NBEMS DNB CET 2027 Information Bulletin and reproduced in the allotment letter. Always cross-check both before the reporting date. Individual hospitals may require additional documents such as a medical fitness certificate or NOC from employer — contact the hospital administration directly in advance.
How Much Money is Needed for DNB CET Counselling 2027?
DNB CET counselling involves two separate fee payments: a non-refundable counselling registration fee and a first-year course fee to confirm seat allotment. This differs from MCC NEET counselling, which uses a separate refundable security deposit model — in NBEMS DNB counselling, the seat-confirmation payment is the first installment of the actual training fee.
Non-Refundable Registration Fee
Every student who registers for counselling pays this fee upfront before choice filling. It is non-refundable under all circumstances — whether or not a seat is allotted, whether you confirm or withdraw, whether you participate in all rounds or drop out after Round 1.
| Category | Registration Fee (Expected 2027) | Refundable? |
|---|---|---|
| All categories (General / OBC-NCL / SC / ST / EWS / PwBD) | ₹2,500 | No — non-refundable in all cases |
Based on the 2026 cycle, NBEMS charged a flat ₹2,500 with no category-based differential — unlike some other counselling bodies that charge lower fees for reserved categories. The 2027 fee will be confirmed in the official notification; the 2026 amount is used here as the baseline estimate.
Course Fee and Hospital Deposit
After receiving a seat allotment, you must pay the first-year course fee to freeze and confirm your seat. Based on the 2026 NBEMS structure, private and charitable hospital DNB seats carry a one-year non-refundable course fee of ₹1,25,000. Government hospital seats operate differently — trainees receive a monthly stipend with no upfront course fee. If you withdraw after accepting a seat, the seat acceptance fee is not fully refunded.
| Seat / Hospital Type | First-Year Fee (Expected 2027) | Refund if You Do Not Join / Withdraw |
|---|---|---|
| Private / Charitable Hospital DNB seat | ₹1,25,000 (per year) | Non-refundable once paid to confirm allotment |
| Government Hospital DNB seat | Stipend-based — monthly stipend paid to trainee; no upfront course fee | Not applicable (no fee collected) |
Government hospital DNB seats are comparatively fewer in the seat matrix but carry a significant financial advantage — no upfront payment and a monthly stipend. Private hospital seats require the ₹1,25,000 upfront commitment. Hospitals may also charge additional one-time deposits or infrastructure fees at joining — confirm the full fee structure with your allotted hospital before reporting.
Note: The ₹1,25,000 figure is from the 2026 NBEMS cycle and may be revised for 2027. The exact amount will be stated in the 2027 allotment letter and NBEMS information bulletin. Never pay any fee through unofficial channels.
DNB CET 2027 Round-Wise Seat Allotment
DNB CET 2027 counselling runs across four rounds. Seats not confirmed in any round — due to non-response, non-payment, or withdrawal — are returned to the pool for the next round. This makes participation in every round important: better seats become available as students higher up in the merit list confirm their choices or exit.
| Round | Mode | Expected Period (2027) | Seat Pool | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Round 1 | Online (counseling.nbe.edu.in) | 1st–2nd week of July 2027 | Full available seat matrix — all hospitals and specialties | Upcoming |
| Round 2 | Online (counseling.nbe.edu.in) | August 2027 | Seats not confirmed or surrendered after Round 1 | Upcoming |
| Round 3 | Online (counseling.nbe.edu.in) | August / September 2027 | Seats remaining after Round 2 | Upcoming |
| Offline Mop-Up Round | Offline — in person at NBEMS-designated venue | September / October 2027 | Residual vacant seats after all three online rounds; held only if seats remain | Upcoming |
The 2026 cycle showed how compressed the Round 1 window is — registration opened July 2 and allotment was declared July 9, leaving just five working days for choice filling. Prepare your preference list, fee payment method, and documents before registration opens so you are not scrambling within the window. This cycle’s Round 1 timing is expected to be similarly tight.
Eligibility for the offline mop-up round is announced separately by NBEMS. Students who participated online but did not receive a confirmed seat through Round 3 are typically eligible, but check the official notification for the exact eligibility conditions for each mop-up round.
Upgrade, Freeze, or Withdraw — Which Option to Choose?
After a seat is allotted in any online round, you must exercise one of three options before the deadline. This is the most consequential decision in the process — your choice directly determines your financial exposure and whether you remain in the running for a better allotment.
| Option | What It Means | Effect on the Next Round | Effect on Course Fee Paid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Freeze | Accept the current allotment as final — no further upgrade sought | Not eligible for allotment in the next round; reporting proceeds from the current allotment | Fee is applied toward the first year of training at the confirmed hospital |
| Upgrade (Float) | Accept the current allotment as a safety net, but wish to be considered for a higher-preference choice in the next round | Automatically considered for better-ranked choices; current seat held if no upgrade is found | Fee is held and transferred to whichever seat you ultimately confirm |
| Withdraw | Surrender the allotted seat entirely and exit the counselling process | Not eligible for further online rounds in the same cycle | Fee paid is forfeited — not refunded |
If you withdraw after accepting a seat, the seat acceptance fee is not fully refunded. The risk-free default for most students is "Upgrade" — you keep your current seat as a backup while the system checks whether your higher-ranked preferences have opened up in the next round. Use "Freeze" only when you are completely satisfied with the current allotment and do not want any risk of it being reassigned. Use "Withdraw" only if you have definitively decided not to pursue DNB training through this cycle.
Students who received no allotment in a given round are automatically eligible for the next round — no additional action is required. Their locked preferences from the previous window carry forward unless they modify them during the next round’s choice filling window.
Reporting to Your Allotted Hospital After DNB CET Counselling
Reporting to the hospital is the only offline step in the counselling process. After confirming your allotment online by paying the first-year course fee, download the official allotment letter from counseling.nbe.edu.in and report to the hospital within the deadline stated in the letter.
- Download the allotment letter from the NBEMS counselling portal immediately after course fee payment — this is your joining authorization document.
- Gather all original documents and prepare two complete sets of self-attested photocopies before travelling (see the Documents Required section for the full list).
- Report in person to the hospital’s academic or administrative department on or before the deadline — there is no grace period.
- The hospital conducts document verification; any discrepancy — expired category certificate, diploma certificate from an unrecognised institution, mismatched personal details — can result in enrollment denial.
- Submit original degree and diploma certificates as per hospital policy; these are typically retained as security and returned on successful program completion.
- Pay any additional hospital-specific joining deposit or infrastructure fee, if applicable, as communicated by the hospital before reporting.
- Obtain your formal joining letter from the hospital and complete the NBEMS reporting formalities through the portal as instructed in the allotment letter.
Missing the reporting deadline triggers automatic seat cancellation by NBEMS. The first-year course fee you paid to confirm the allotment is forfeited — not refunded. Plan your travel and document preparation at least one week before the deadline; last-minute rushes are the leading cause of missed reporting dates.
Note: Some hospitals require documents beyond the NBEMS standard list — such as a medical fitness certificate, character certificate, or NOC from employer (if you are currently working). Contact the allotted hospital’s administration directly as soon as your allotment is confirmed to get their specific joining requirements.
FAQs
Ques: What is DNB CET Counselling 2027 and who conducts it?
Ans: DNB CET Counselling 2027 — officially called DNB PDCET (Post Diploma Centralized Entrance Test) Counselling — is the centralised online seat allocation process for admission to DNB Post Diploma programs in NBEMS-accredited hospitals. NBEMS (National Board of Examinations in Medical Sciences) conducts the entire process through its portal counseling.nbe.edu.in. Approximately 1,000+ seats across 600+ hospitals in 14 broad specialties are filled across four rounds — three online and one offline mop-up round — based on merit rank and locked preferences.
Ques: When will DNB CET 2027 counselling registration begin?
Ans: Based on the 2026 cycle — where the exam was held April 12, result declared May 14, and Round 1 registration opened July 2 — the 2027 counselling registration is expected to open in the first week of July 2027. NBEMS does not pre-announce the full schedule; it is released progressively round by round after the result. Monitor counseling.nbe.edu.in and natboard.edu.in from May 2027 onwards. As of September 2026, the 2027 schedule has not been released.
Ques: What are the eligibility conditions for DNB CET 2027 counselling?
Ans: You must have a valid DNB CET 2027 merit rank, an MBBS degree from a NMC/MCI-recognised institution, a Post Graduate Diploma pass certificate in the relevant specialty (with the result declared on or before the NBEMS-specified cutoff date), permanent MCI/NMC or State Medical Council registration, and a completed 12-month rotating internship. Foreign medical graduates must additionally hold a valid FMGE/NExT pass certificate and NMC registration. The detailed eligibility conditions are published in the NBEMS Information Bulletin for 2027.
Ques: How many rounds does DNB CET 2027 counselling have?
Ans: DNB CET 2027 counselling has four rounds: three online rounds (Round 1, Round 2, Round 3) conducted through counseling.nbe.edu.in, and one offline mop-up round held in person at an NBEMS-designated venue if vacant seats remain after Round 3. A single registration at the start of Round 1 covers all rounds — you do not re-register. NBEMS releases each round’s dates progressively, not all at once.
Ques: What is the counselling registration fee for DNB CET 2027?
Ans: Based on the 2026 cycle, NBEMS charges a flat ₹2,500 counselling registration fee for all categories — General, OBC-NCL, SC, ST, EWS, and PwBD alike. This fee is paid online (Net Banking, Debit/Credit Card, UPI) and is non-refundable under all circumstances. The 2027 fee will be confirmed in the official notification; ₹2,500 is the 2026 baseline. No refund is issued regardless of allotment status or withdrawal.
Ques: How many choices should I fill in DNB CET 2027 counselling?
Ans: You should fill a minimum of 15–20 choices. More choices directly improve your probability of getting an allotment — especially across multiple specialties or hospitals in different states. Fill at least 15–20 choices to maximise your chances across all rounds. Choices can be added, removed, and reordered at any point before the locking deadline. After locking, no modifications are possible for that round.
Ques: What is the difference between Freeze, Upgrade, and Withdraw in DNB CET counselling?
Ans: These are the three options you exercise after a round allots you a seat. Freeze means you accept the current seat as final and do not participate in further rounds. Upgrade (float) means you accept the current seat as a safety net but remain eligible to be moved to a higher-preference option in the next round — your current seat is held if no upgrade is found. Withdraw means you surrender the seat entirely and exit the cycle; the course fee paid is forfeited. For most students, Upgrade is the safest choice because it retains the current allotment while keeping the door open for a better option.
Ques: Is the course fee refundable after DNB CET seat allotment?
Ans: No — the first-year course fee (approximately ₹1,25,000 for private hospital seats, based on the 2026 structure) is non-refundable once paid to confirm a seat. If you withdraw after accepting a seat, the seat acceptance fee is not fully refunded. If you are still hoping for a better allotment, choose the Upgrade option rather than Withdraw — Upgrade retains your seat while keeping you in the running, without the financial penalty of withdrawal.
Ques: What documents must I carry when reporting to the allotted hospital?
Ans: Carry originals plus two self-attested photocopies each of: MBBS degree and mark sheets, Post Graduate Diploma pass certificate, MCI/NMC registration certificate, internship completion certificate, DNB CET 2027 admit card, score card, allotment letter, identity proof, category certificate (if applicable), passport-size photographs, and fee payment receipts. The allotment letter from NBEMS also lists any hospital-specific documents required at that hospital. Contact the hospital administration directly before your reporting date to confirm their complete requirements.
Ques: Can I participate in the offline mop-up round if I did not get a seat in the online rounds?
Ans: Students who participated in online rounds but did not receive or confirm any allotment through Round 3 are typically eligible for the offline mop-up round, subject to NBEMS’s specific conditions published at the time. The mop-up round is conducted in person and fills any residual vacant seats. NBEMS announces mop-up eligibility, venue, and dates separately after Round 3 — check the official portal for the exact conditions for 2027.
Ques: What happens if I miss the hospital reporting deadline after confirming my seat?
Ans: Missing the reporting deadline results in NBEMS automatically cancelling your seat. The first-year course fee paid to confirm the allotment is forfeited — not refunded. The vacated seat is returned to the pool for subsequent rounds or the mop-up round. There is no grace period or extension process. Given the compressed counselling window — based on the 2026 cycle, Round 1 had barely a week from allotment to reporting — arrange your documents and travel before the allotment result to avoid any last-minute problems.
Disclaimer: The DNB CET 2027 counselling schedule, fees, and procedures presented in this article are projected based on the 2026 cycle (NBEMS) and have not yet been officially confirmed for 2027. As of September 2026, the 2027 exam and counselling cycle has not commenced. Always verify all information from the official NBEMS portal at nbe.edu.in / natboard.edu.in and the official DNB CET 2027 Information Bulletin before registering or making any payments.








Comments