A good way to settle this is a quick visit or video call with current students. Ask an LPU MBA student and an Amity HRM student about the same things:
Online, you will find a mixture of views. An LPU student says the two are comparable and suggests LPU may have a slight edge in MBA. An LPU alumnus now at TCS reports good placements. Some others are harshly critical, and a few say private-college placements are generally overstated. Student conversations help you see where reality sits in this range.
Combine what you hear with documented numbers: median package, share placed, recruiters and total cost. If you are certain about a career in HR, the specialised programme is reasonable when its outcomes are real. If not, the general MBA is more flexible. Choose the one that gives you the clearest proof and a manageable cost.
Some honest scepticism is useful with any private university. Commenters say placement claims at private colleges are frequently oversold, and one even calls LPU a poor choice, while an LPU alumnus now at TCS says most of their friends were placed. This spread suggests outcomes depend on the student and the stream.
For HR in particular, ask Amity for placement details specific to the HRM stream. Many programmes show only university-wide numbers that do not reflect a specialised batch. Ask LPU what share of its MBA students choose HR and what roles they get.
Also do some of your own research: look up alumni of each programme on LinkedIn and see where they work and in what roles. If you cannot find many HR professionals from a programme, that is informative. Combine this with the total cost and your own certainty about HR as a career, and choose the option that you can justify with facts.
Think about the type of employer you want. HR roles in large companies are concentrated in metro regions, and Amity Noida's location in the NCR makes it easier to interact with them during the degree. If your target is a large corporate in Delhi, Gurgaon or Noida, that is a practical advantage.
LPU, on the other hand, offers a bigger campus and a business school reported to have international accreditation, along with a wide range of activities. A student there suggests LPU may be slightly better for MBA, and an alumnus working at TCS speaks well of placements, though others strongly disagree.
Whichever you choose, ask for proof rather than reputation. Request HR-specific placement outcomes from Amity and the MBA outcomes from LPU, including median salary and recruiter lists. Combine that with the total cost, and weigh whether you are ready to commit to HR right away. If not, the general MBA is the safer pick.
If you want a general MBA and are comparing it with a focused HR programme, the key question is how certain you are about HR. A general MBA at LPU lets you decide later, while Amity's HRM degree commits you from day one but can provide deeper coursework in the area.
Students describe the two universities as comparable in education quality. An LPU student believes LPU may have a slight edge for MBA overall, and Amity is often credited with a stronger brand and a convenient NCR location. Treat these as impressions, since they are not specific to HR.
Get proper numbers before deciding. Ask each university for placement data for the stream you would study:
If you are still unsure about HR, choose the more flexible degree. If you are sure, choose the one with clearer HR outcomes and a fee that fits your budget.
Cost deserves equal weight with reputation. Compare the full programme fees for LPU's MBA and Amity's HRM programme, then add hostel, food and living costs. A student comparing the two universities notes that outcomes are broadly similar, so a significant fee difference should count.
It is also reasonable to be cautious about borrowing. Students looking at private universities commonly advise against heavy loans when the job market is uncertain, particularly for fields where starting pay may be modest. HR roles in particular can start at moderate salaries, so check what recent graduates earn before you plan repayments.
If the two programmes show similar outcomes, the cheaper one is usually the better pick. If Amity's brand and NCR location lead to better documented results in HR, a higher fee may be justified. Ask both for scholarships, fee instalments and recent salary data, and decide only after you have the numbers.
Amity University Noida, Noida