Evolution Vs Progress: Definition, Types And Comparison

Namrata Das logo

Namrata Das

Exams Prep Master

The origin of life forms on planet earth, their evolution, and how biodiversity continues to thrive are explained by various theories. The surroundings have drastically changed over millions of years hinting at a history of life forms that have made the earth their home. The origin of the universe is based on the Big Bang Theory which explains the formation of our solar system and the milky way galaxy. Earth is believed to have been formed much later (about 4.5 million years ago). Gradually, the ozone layer was formed and as the conditions turned favorable, oceans and life-forms dependent on it began to exist. Numerous other theories like that from the early Greeks also suggest life has come from Spores. Let us understand some important aspects of the evolution of life-forms on earth and get an insight into the diversity of this biodiversity.

Key Takeaways: Evolution, Progress, Biodiversity, Charles Darwin, Natural Selection, Convergent, Divergent, Reverse, Forces of Evolution

Also Read: Reproductive Health


Understanding Evolution

[Click Here for Sample Questions]

The theory of evolution suggests that an old species of a particular life form undergoes changes in its physical characteristics over several generations. These changes are not predetermined but are based on the environment in which the organism species thrive over their lifetime. However, the following three connotations form the basis for this theory.

  1. All species of organisms are related to each other and the change occurs gradually over time.
  2. Evolution solely depends on the variation caused by genes in a particular organism population which further affects the physical property of the organism.
  3. Some of these characteristics make one individual of the population have an advantage over the other. These traits further get transferred to the offspring.

The evolution trend in the species was first explained by Charles Darwin to be based on the ‘theory of natural selection.’


Charles Darwin’s Theory of Evolution

[Click Here for Sample Questions]

This theory forms a solid base for evolution seen in the various life forms on earth. Organisms evolve from inheriting some of their physical or behavioral traits. Let us consider a population, The individuals in this population have varied traits. Some survive and adapt to the environmental changes and the others do not. Sometimes, the key traits that facilitated survival are carried over onto the next generation of the species. The lesser adaptive individuals have lesser survival rates causing them to eventually reduce in number. The population becomes richer in individuals and their offspring possessing traits like changes in skin color, or modification of certain body parts that help them adapt to the changing environmental conditions. 

Thus genetically modified individuals could be formed from a common ancestor and this happens very gradually where the changes accumulate over time, sometimes creating entirely new species.

A classic example is that of the evolution of whales from land to marine animals. The tail flukes, absence of the front and hind limbs, nostrils above their head are all a result of this gradual evolution. The present species of whales hence do not have to come out onto the surface of the water to breathe.

Also Read:


Types of Evolution

[Click Here for Sample Questions]

Environmental factors and predation pressures form the basis for evolution. Adapting to changes for survival, narrowed down the population of ancestral species thereby forming a new population with more frequent survival traits. Let us now look at some of the evolution types observed across different life forms.

  1. Convergent Evolution

A flying insect, bird, and bat are classic examples of this type of evolution. We see that all these three species have evolved the ability to fly but do not have a common ancestor. Species that share their traits owing to similar environmental conditions where they thrive for survival but have varied ancestry come under the category of convergently evolving species.

  1. Divergent Evolution

A human arm, a bat’s wing, and a whale’s fin are all limbs that perform varied functions. All the three species have however evolved from a common ancestor which had these bone structures. This is divergent evolution. Two or more species share a common ancestor but become increasingly different over time.

  1. Co-evolution

We see flowering plants evolve in terms of their leaf and flower shapes, color, and sizes. Accordingly, pollinating insects like bees evolve too. This is a classic example of co-evolution where two different species evolve alongside each other and one adapts to the changes in the other.

  1. Adaptive Radiation

Darwin’s finches or the finches from Galapagos islands have evolved with different beak shapes over time. This is an example of adaptive radiation. One species splits its physical characteristics into many newer forms when a new resource becomes available in the environment or a new challenge is created.

Four species of Darwin’s Finches on the Galapagos islands show variation in beak

Four species of Darwin’s Finches on the Galapagos islands show variation in beak

  1. Reverse Evolution

Penguins have become flightless birds. Snake species have lost legs. These are examples of reverse evolution. These species have adapted and evolved with traits that are reduced from their ancestors or are no longer needed.


Evolution vs Porgress

[Click Here for Sample Questions]

Evolution in basic terms is a gradual process that accumulates changes and is dependent on environmental conditions like temperature, climate, etc. Progress, however, is advancement through a series of events or developments occurring through time. This is independent of the environmental factors.

All species must be capable of adapting to their niche. Sometimes their existing body structures pose a hindrance and thus their survival falls at risk. This is where the evolution process gets initiated. The ancestral species start becoming defective as existing environmental conditions turn unfavorable to them. This modification cannot be mistaken as progress. This is the organism adapting to the modification as demanded by its surrounding. The genes thus play a very important role in variation which becomes the primary factor for evolution. The organism now has a better probability to survive thereby preventing its extinction.

Progress, on the other hand, is upgrading of levels wherein the next level is better than the previous one. Let us take the example of Humans and Chimpanzees. It will be wrong to say that humans have evolved from chimpanzees or that humans are more evolved than chimpanzees. Both these species have a common ancestor who may or may not look like a chimpanzee. Thus these two species only have common traits but are not evolved from one another.

When the body design gets altered, one should not confuse it with progress. This would indicate that many organisms which exist now would not have due to natural selection. Bacteria is a unicellular and prokaryotic organism that is found almost everywhere and can survive even the harshest conditions. However, humans on the other hand have their limitations owing to their body design. The bacteria are far more advanced and can even develop resistance in comparison to humans.

Also Read:


Things to Remember

  • Evolution is a gradual generational change in the physical attributes of a species in response to environmental conditions it thrives in.
  • Darwin’s theory of natural selection forms the basis for the evolution of living forms on eath.
  • According to the theory of natural selection, organisms evolve by inheriting certain physical or behavioral traits that help them in surviving and adapt to the environment.
  • Evolution is classified as convergent, divergent, co-evolution, adaptive radiation, and reverse evolution.
  • Evolution does not imply elimination but it is related to one species arising from another existing species. The new versions may or may not be better than the old ones.
  • Progress is an up-gradation or an advancement in levels that takes place within a species. It is independent of the environmental factors surrounding a species and causes one population to be better than the other.
  • Natural selection, speciation, and genetic drift have played key roles in shaping the biodiversity on earth.

Sample Questions

Ques: Differentiate between convergent and divergent evolution. (2 marks)

Ans: 

Convergent Evolution Divergent Evolution
Unrelated species evolve with similar characteristics. Species become different from their ancestors.
Caused by environmental changes. Caused by environmental changes and migration
Example: wings of insects and bats Example: Finches from Galapagos islands

Ques: What roles do genes play in evolution? (2 marks)

Ans: Evolution gets initiated when certain individuals in a species adapt better to the niche and the surrounding in comparison to other individuals in the same population. This happens at the genomic level. This causes alteration in the DNA sequences which accumulate over time and sometimes prove beneficial for the survival of the organism. When two or more species share their ancestors, we see that their DNA and genes are similar.

Ques: Define the forces of evolution? (4 marks)

Ans: The important forces for human evolution are as follows:

  1. Natural Selection

Humans reproduce and this keeps paves way for evolution. Variation in genetic information over several generations along with natural selection (traits that facilitate survival and sustenance of species) are pillars of human evolution.

  1. Genetic Drift

When the frequency of an existing gene variant in a population changes due to random sampling of organisms, the ability to survive and further reproduce is based on the alleles in the offspring.

  1. Mutation

Error in DNA copying causes mutation to take place. Mutation can be somatic wherein all cells apart from gametes are affected. Germinal mutation takes place only on those cells which get converted into gametes.

  1. Population Mating Structure

These include behavioral, temporal, and physiological factors that cause non-random mating among individuals in a population.

Ques: Are organisms always getting better through evolution? (2 marks)

Ans: Evolution occurs in life forms by natural selection which enhances their abilities to survive and reproduce. But this should not be mistaken for progress. Evolution is not always necessary for a species to persist but it allows the survival of species that are ‘good enough.’ Apart from this mutation, migration, and genetic drift can cause an overall harmful form of evolution.

Ques: Does natural selection give an organism what it needs? (2 marks)

Ans: Genetic variation is a part of natural selection and happens by random mutation. The evolution of a population occurs when some individuals in the population have traits that allow them to survive the environmental challenge and reproduce. The absence of a genetic variation may cause the population to survive or sometimes die out.

For Latest Updates on Upcoming Board Exams, Click Here: https://t.me/class_10_12_board_updates


Check-Out: 

CBSE CLASS XII Related Questions

  • 1.
    Work out the crosses between:
    Normal female and Haemophilic male
    Carrier female and Normal male
    (III) Carrier female and Haemophilic male
    Write the conclusions you draw from these crosses. Comment on the type of inheritance of the disease.
    (Use: $X$ - Normal, $X^h$ - Haemophilic)


      • 2.
        Explain any two basic principles/core techniques on which biotechnology is based.
        Describe any three key tools used in Recombinant DNA technology.


          • 3.
            What is meant by translation in protein synthesis?
            Explain charging of tRNA (aminoacylation of tRNA) and mention its importance in the process of translation.


              • 4.
                Read the following passage and answer the questions that follow:
                India is one of the megadiverse countries housing around 8·1 per cent of global species diversity, although its land area is only 2·4 per cent of the world’s land area. Many of the species are highly threatened due to human activities like deforestation, mining and habitat fragmentation. Laws like Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 were enacted by the Government of India to preserve our biological wealth. Various conservation measures are being implemented to save the threatened species. The following bar graph shows the number of species conserved under different biodiversity conservation methods.

                Which other methods shown in the diagram are opposite to the one identified by you in question ? How are these two conservation approaches different?
                (c) Write two features of Biodiversity hotspots.
                (c) To which category do sacred groves belong and how do they help in bio-conservation?


                  • 5.

                    Read the following passage and answer the questions that follow: 
                    The data below shows the concentration of nicotine smoked by a smoker taking 10puffs/minute.
                     


                      • 6.
                        Draw a labelled two-celled structure of male gametophyte of an angiosperm.
                        Name the three layers that surround the cytoplasm of a male gametophyte starting from innermost to outermost layer.
                        (iii) Which organic material makes the outermost layer? Mention its advantage.
                        (iv) Why is the outermost layer of male gametophyte not continuous ?

                          CBSE CLASS XII Previous Year Papers

                          Comments


                          No Comments To Show